Our card this week is Norris Evans, the Jack of Spades from New York.

In the spring of 1975, Norris was living in Rochester, raising four young kids.

But one night, someone entered her home and brutally attacked her, nearly decapitating her,

while her children were upstairs.

Now, more than 50 years later, those same children are reopening old wounds, hoping that

her killer or killers will be brought to justice.

I'm Ashley Flowers, and this is the deck.

Thank you. I'm Ashley Flowers, and this is the deck. It was 11.24 p.m. on a Friday night, May 23, 1975, when a man who refused to give his name called Rochester, New York police dispatch to tell them that there was some kind of family trouble at

5 Crone Street. Then he hung up quickly without saying much else.

Rochester investigator Seth Carr shared reports with us, which show that within 16 minutes,

an officer was pulling up at the corner duplex. When he got to the location, he notes that

it's dark, there's no activity. Kns on the door, doesn't get a response.

He made a mental note or recalled that there were people on a porch across the street,

but everything seemed in order.

He didn't find a complaint or any victim.

The officer stayed for a few minutes, even shined his flashlight in the windows,

but he didn't see or hear anything alarming.

So he got back in his patrol car and left. But less than an hour later, police got a second

call about the same address. This caller wasn't anonymous, though. It was a man named Tom who

lived in the other half of the duplex.

He said that his neighbor, 26-year-old Lewis Evans, had just shown up and asked him to make the call because his wife was next door and she'd been hurt.

The same officer who had originally been dispatched to Five Crohn Street returned, and this, it wasn't quiet and dark. Lewis was outside

...