meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
BibleThinker

Necromancy in the Bible: The Witch of Endor

BibleThinker

Mike Winger

Christianity, Religion & Spirituality

4.82.6K Ratings

🗓️ 4 July 2021

⏱️ 6 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

There's a passage in the Bible that, according to some, shows necromancy working in the real world. Here are my thoughts on what we can learn about the legitimacy of necromancy from this text. Anti-supernaturalists would deny it and sensationalists might want to use it to say too much. But I will offer my own theory as to what was going on when the witch at Endor was used to try to access Samuel after he died and Samuel actually showed up! This is just one question from a long interview I did for the moderators of the r/Bible subreddit. They asked their subreddit to send me a bunch of questions and I spent a lot of time preparing so that I would be able to offer the best answers I could. I'll be posting these answers as individual videos so keep an eye out for the rest in the set.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

One of the questions is, does this mean that mediums are legit, because this medium actually

0:04.9

called up Samuel, like what's up with that? You actually called him up. It was really Samuel.

0:10.5

That's how the text seems to read.

0:15.3

So our next question will come from clinky07l. First Samuel 28. Let's up with this. I have a

0:24.0

million questions about the passage, but could you break it down?

0:27.3

Okay. Well, that gives me a lot of areas to go to. Let me just briefly summarize it. Okay.

0:35.2

King Saul, in for Samuel 28, Saul is king. He's kind of like the lousy king before David shows up.

0:41.0

And he's scared, because the Philistines are about to tack Israel. They're outnumbered. He's

0:45.6

worried, right? And God will not speak to Saul. Normally, God would speak through dreams,

0:50.6

the erim, or prophets. These are the terms used. Dreams would be either personally or through other

0:56.0

people who are getting dreams from God. The erim, this is something the high priest had, the

1:00.4

erim and them. And there was somehow, we don't know how they were used. There were somehow used

1:03.7

in helping to determine God's will in the context of the tabernacle at the time. And God won't

1:08.8

speak to him that way. And he won't speak through the prophets. God's typical guides for kings.

1:13.2

And add to this the complexity that Samuel has just died. Okay. Samuel was like the prophet

1:18.4

who inointed Saul and kind of was, he was like a counselor for Saul, telling him what to do.

1:23.2

But he wouldn't listen. Saul wouldn't listen. Finally, Samuel died. So Saul, he's like,

1:27.7

no one will talk to me. Samuel, if I could just get Samuel, I would know what God wants me to do.

1:32.6

And I could, I could have the right plan for defeating the Philistines. So Saul goes to a pagan

1:37.8

medium, someone who's like a spiritist who like contacts the dead. And he goes in disguise,

1:42.8

because he's previously kicked the mediums out of the land. He's removed them from the land.

1:46.3

So they find one who's been in hiding. She's like kind of stealthy there. And he goes in disguise

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Mike Winger, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Mike Winger and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.