meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Switched on Pop

Modern Classics: Carina del Valle Schorske on Cat Power's "Manhattan"

Switched on Pop

Vox Media Podcast Network

Music Interviews, Music History, Music, Music Commentary

4.6 • 2.7K Ratings

🗓️ 31 August 2021

⏱️ 30 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Recently the hosts of Switched on Pop kept seeing the same byline next to their favorite pieces of music writing. A moving profile of Bad Bunny? There was the name. A searing critique of West Side Story? There it was again. An elegy on love, loss, and an Aretha Franklin and Smokey Robinson duet? By now it was committed to memory: writer and translator Carina del Valle Schorske. So we knew we had to invite Carina to participate in our Modern Classics series and learn what this brilliant writer would place in her modern pop pantheon. Carina’s pick, the 2012 song “Manhattan” by Cat Power, presents an opportunity to analyze an artist we’ve never discussed on the show before, and a song that sparks associations with New York City’s rich musical history. Cat Power, aka Chan Marshall, released “Manhattan” on her 2012 album Sun, and the song—on which Marshall recorded every instrument herself—has become an unlikely sleeper hit in the Cat Power catalog. Perhaps that’s because, as Carina tells it, the song is a celebration and elegy at once, trying to capture the beat of a city that is constantly in flux, but with an inescapable iconicity. “Manhattan” isn’t the only piece of urban musical alchemy Carina brought to the show. Cat Power’s ode to the borough syncs up in surprising ways with the 1978 salsa track by Willie Colón and Rubén Blades, “Buscando Guayaba.” Together, the songs stake out a twisting path across genre, time, and language, but along on the same streets. Songs Discussed Cat Power - Manhattan Rubén Blades and Willie Colón - Buscando Guayaba, Pedro Navaja Ella Fitzgerald - Manhattan Stevie Wonder - Livin’ for the City Alicia Keys and Jay Z - Empire State of Mind Check out Carina’s profile of Bad Bunny, her essay on Aretha Franklin and Smokey Robinson, and more writing at her website. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Stream the new Paramount Plus original series 1923 a Yellowstone origin story starring Helen Mirren in Harrison Ford

0:08.3

1923 a new series streaming now exclusively on Paramount Plus go to Paramount Plus comm to try it for free

0:14.6

Welcome to Switched on Pop I'm musicologist Nate Sloan and this is the latest installment of modern classics where we talk to our favorite musicians and writers about the songs that they think belong in the pantheon of Pop.

0:41.6

Our guest today is someone I've wanted to speak to since I started seeing their byline attached to all of the best music writing of the last few years.

0:50.6

Profile of bad money there they were a searing critique of West Side Story there they were again a beautiful introduction to the Bay Area musician La Donia.

0:59.6

There it was again I'm pleased to welcome the person responsible for all of these pieces and more the writer and translator Karina Delvae Shorsky.

1:10.6

Karina thank you so much for joining us.

1:12.6

Thank you you nailed it on the pronunciation to amazing I may have practiced a dozen times may have not will never know multilingual music.

1:23.6

Thank you Karina what song have you brought for us today well the song that I selected today is that cat powers Manhattan let's listen to some of Manhattan by cat power right now.

1:38.6

Don't look at the moon tonight. You'll never be never be never be.

1:48.6

Cat power aka Sean Marshall released her first album in 1995 and her most recent in 2018 this song Manhattan is from her 2012 album Sun and which she plays virtually every instrument we're hearing herself.

2:12.6

Karina do you remember when you first heard the song.

2:15.6

It's so embarrassing and I knew that I would have to tell the truth on the podcast that the fucking Spotify algorithm fed it to me.

2:23.6

No shame in the Spotify algorithm game.

2:27.6

I did listen to a decent amount of cat power but I definitely heard it for the first time during my early years of living in Manhattan as an adult.

2:38.6

I grew up in the Bay area but my mom grew up in Manhattan and in Washington Heights specifically and my family lived there in Washington Heights in the same apartment for 65 years until December when my grandmother passed away.

2:55.6

So coming to live in Manhattan I guess seven years ago or so to do a peach yet Columbia like adjacent to the neighborhood that was like my family's neighborhood setting up shop in my studio apartment and admitting to myself that I wanted to be a writer and that I wanted to try that in New York was the period in which I was introduced by the Spotify algorithm to this song and it was an immediate hit with me.

3:21.6

So I love that Kizmit. I mean Spotify recommends us a lot of songs but maybe not all of them connect and so kind of perfect away.

3:31.6

Were there any particular lyrics that really resonated with you?

3:36.6

Yes. I mean I actually wondered what counts as pop first switched on pop and I think that this is probably like on the indie side of pop.

3:46.6

But to me it still counts to me almost every song about New York is a pop song because and like an including jazz because it's engaging with this iconic popular symbol not only for the US but for the entire world.

4:03.6

And so you're always going to be participating a little bit even by saying the word Manhattan and that kind of conversation I think but other than that the lyrics of this song are like as non pop song as you can get in some ways.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Vox Media Podcast Network, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Vox Media Podcast Network and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.