This is Murder She Told, true crime stories from Maine, New England, and small town USA.

I'm your host, Kristen Ceevy.

You can connect with me at MurderSheTold.com or follow on Instagram at MurderSheToldPodcast.

Do you know this man? Do you recognize his hat? It's a cherry-red trucker cap with a white logo on its face.

It's brim, by today's standards, is oddly short, but its length wasn't unusual in the early 80s.

Do you recognize his outfit? Dark green coveralls that zip up the front over an orange t-shirt,

where they part of a work uniform? Do you know his town? He likely lived near Port Smith, New Hampshire,

in Exeter or Stratham. He was white, about six feet tall and lean. He had chestnut brown hair

about shoulder length and a full beard. If we find him, we may find the answer to this question.

Where is Reeves Johnson? This case is special. We've never before had complete

access to any case like we do this one. Thanks to the transparency and support of the local

detective working on the case, we have been brought into the fold of the investigating team that

is searching for answers to a decade's old mystery. Listen closely to this episode. You could

be the one to break this case wide open. Sally was the oldest. She arrived in the world in the fall

of 1949 and her mother, Barbara, gave birth to a son, Sally's younger brother Reeves,

just one year and ten months later on the final day of September of 1951.

One year later, in 1952, the family unit would be complete with the arrival of Hugh Johnson,

the youngest of the trio of siblings. Their parents, Camp and Barbara lived in a sparsely

populated excerb of Philadelphia called Broadax, constituted chiefly of large farms,

unique single-family homes, and some well-to-do neighborhoods. They were boxed in by agriculture,

cornfields behind them, and dairy cows next door, an idyllic countryside backdrop to their historic

Pennsylvania fieldstone farmhouse built 200 years prior to the Johnson's taking up residence.

...