meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Evan & Tiki

Mike McCarthy Gets Disrespected By Too Many

Evan & Tiki

Audacy

Sports

4.2988 Ratings

🗓️ 7 November 2025

⏱️ 11 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Mike McCarthy could be a logical Giants Head Coach

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

So he gets credit for it.

0:01.7

Of course he does.

0:02.7

I don't think you hesitated at all when I said is Sean Payton doing a good job.

0:06.2

Yes.

0:06.8

Because he's ultimately he's winning.

0:09.9

He's finding ways to win games.

0:12.0

And ultimately, Brian Daybold is losing.

0:14.4

Yes.

0:14.7

Finding ways to lose games.

0:17.0

This offense could be fifth best in the league.

0:18.8

By the way, it's not.

0:19.5

But let's say it was, we can give them all the credit for the offense.

0:22.3

You're still the head coach and you need to win games.

0:24.2

And you're responsible for every aspect of your team, much like Sean Payton.

0:28.2

So now the difference is Sean Peyton has been around for such a long time that even though we think of them as an offensive-minded guy, you have an 18-year career, you've won a Super Bowl, you're all encompassing.

0:38.0

That's when you know you're a good head coach, when we stop with these stupid labels. Right. Like, I want to not think of Aaron Glenn as a former defensive coordinator or former cornerback for the New York Tets. I want to think of him as an all-around head coach. Most people don't even remember where John Harbaugh came from in terms of his background. Most people don't remember at all where Mike Tomlin came from his background. When you're that good, it doesn't matter. Right. I mean, he's been, what is it? 17 years? No, 16 years. For Tomlin? Yeah, I think so. That's crazy. Have we gotten to that point with McVeigh yet? Were we stop thinking of as the offensive guy and as a head coach? We don't only because he's so freaking amazing at it, but yes, he's a head coach. And he's won a Super Bowl. So I think once you win a Super Bowl, it becomes less about, I scheme this thing perfectly, and that's why we won because we just outscored the opponent. I think it's more about success than, you know, what's his offense rank? 19th season for Mike Tomlin. His 19th season, he has had zero losing seasons,

1:29.1

but three 500 seasons. Oh, sorry. Sorry. Sign me up. If we had a 500 season, which I know

1:36.3

is tougher because of the odd amount of games, we'd have a parade here in New York. Alan's in Connecticut. What's up, Alan? So I think if I told you the Giants could get a coach that's 15th all time and wins, what would you think about that? On paper, it sounds good. Yeah, I mean, this is the New York Giants.

1:43.8

We are done with his first-time head coach's nonsense. Ben McAdoo, Do Judge, now Daibble, and you can even go Pat Sherman, who didn't have any success at all before they even gave him the job. You had like nine wins. Why don't you go get a guy like Mike McCarthy who's proven who can win,

2:02.6

who can change the culture the way Tibbs change the culture for the next? And then, you know,

2:17.9

if you get to a point four or five years later, then you bring in a closer to finish it off.

2:22.4

But they need to bring in a coach that experience. I love the idea. Oh, I love Mike McCarthy.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Audacy, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Audacy and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.