meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Take One Daf Yomi

Menachot 45 - The Book that Almost Wasn't

Take One Daf Yomi

Tablet Magazine

Judaism, Religion & Spirituality

4.8565 Ratings

🗓️ 25 February 2026

⏱️ 6 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

On today’s page, Menachot 45, we hear the spectacular story of Hananiah ben Hezekiah, the man who saved the Book of Ezekiel from being removed from the biblical canon. Hananiah famously holed himself up in an attic with 300 barrels of oil for illumination until he mastered the text. Guest Dr. Tevi Troy joins us to discuss this kind of scholarly obsession, drawing parallels to American presidents like Abraham Lincoln and Teddy Roosevelt, who went to extreme lengths to satisfy their own hunger for books. What does it mean to love a text so much that you’d risk everything to understand it? Listen and find out.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hey there and welcome back to take one, the podcast that brings you just one spectacular page of Tomlin each day and on today's page. Manachas 45, we read a story that is

0:24.5

spectacular. Indeed, the story of Chanina Ben Chiskaya, who saved the book of Ezekiel from being

0:30.8

decanonized. Imagine going through life without the book of Ezekiel because of irreconcilable

0:35.9

differences with the Torah. He did this by bringing get this, not 100, not 200, but 300 barrels of oil for illumination

0:44.5

into an attic so he could read and master the text and explain how it did not contradict

0:52.3

the Torah.

0:53.4

This kind of act of obsession of sitting there and reading something with kind of like great care to details.

1:01.2

I don't know why, but it kind of brought to my mind the sort of scene in every sort of Hollywood political drama where the kind of crackerjack politician slash congressional aid, what have you,

1:13.2

reads the law very, very, very, very, or the bill very, very carefully.

1:18.3

And kind of, you know, at the last second, nails the one sort of clause that saves the day

1:25.0

and shuts down the naysayers.

1:34.4

So obviously, I did what we always do on this podcast when we have something that suggests the intersection of Tom within American politics and history.

1:38.0

I called our great, our esteemed, our beloved, President de Cherov, Dr. Tevi-Troy,

1:43.7

welcome back. Well, Liel, thanks for having me on to talk about two of my favorite subjects, presidents in Gamara, and also reminding us of the importance of Ezekiel Yechazcal. I could not imagine living without the book of Ezekiel because my Bar Mitzvahaf Torah, which is coming up in a few weeks, was indeed from Ezekiel.

2:01.4

So thank you for reminding us with that.

2:03.3

I will say this.

2:04.8

First of all, that's amazing.

2:06.0

The second of all, Yecheskel is the only prophet about whom a big Israeli band,

2:10.5

the Haranotikvoyim, wrote a really great rock song.

2:14.7

So a beloved perennial staple. But let's go back to this image of, you know,

2:21.3

loving a text so much that you would lock yourself up with 300 barrels of oil into an attic

2:27.7

and read it just so you could fight it because you truly believe that the text isn't just a

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Tablet Magazine, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Tablet Magazine and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.