meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Take One Daf Yomi

Menachot 18 - Valid Mistakes

Take One Daf Yomi

Tablet Magazine

Judaism, Religion & Spirituality

4.8565 Ratings

🗓️ 29 January 2026

⏱️ 15 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

On today’s page, Menachot 18, we find a surprisingly lenient catalog of errors that a priest might make during a sacrificial offering. Even when steps are missed or performed by a non-priest, the Talmud often rules the offering valid, reminding us that the law leaves room for our human tendency to stumble. It is a comforting realization that perfection isn't always the prerequisite for a meaningful connection to the Divine. If even the most sacred rituals allow for mistakes, why are we so hard on ourselves when we fall short? Listen and find out.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hey there, and welcome back to take one, the podcast that brings you just one correct page of Talmud each day.

0:20.2

And on today's page, Menachot 18, we receive, honestly,

0:25.6

a catalog of all the things that could go wrong once the Cohen prepares the sacrificial

0:34.1

offering. What if he did not pour in the oil? What if he did not mix the ingredients together? What if he did not pour in the oil? What if he did not mix the ingredients

0:39.4

together? What if he did not break up the meal offering in pieces? What if he did not salt it?

0:45.0

What if he did not lift it? What if he did not bring it to the altar? It's a long,

0:51.1

long, long list of steps that were skipped, steps that you would really think

0:56.1

were kind of essential. And yet, the rabbis teach us in that case, the offering is valid.

1:01.2

Because the Mishnah incredibly teaches us that while all these things needed to be done,

1:05.6

they didn't necessarily all have to be done according to the highest ideals.

1:11.3

And so even if these activities were performed by an ordinary person who is not a cohen,

1:17.2

these offerings would still be valid.

1:20.8

Look, maybe because it's very cold or because I'm a little bit sick,

1:24.2

or because it's kind of that time of year, you know, late January,

1:27.4

when we really think about all the resolutions we made just a few weeks ago.

1:32.8

But today's stuff really kind of warmed my heart because it reminded me, and I think all of us,

1:39.0

again and again and again, that the Torah doesn't necessarily want us to be absolutely perfect.

1:43.8

It understands that we are likely to mess up again and again and again,

1:48.7

mix up even steps that are important and crucial.

1:52.2

And yet, it forgives us and gives us another opportunity to try again and do better.

1:58.0

And so I want to share with you one of my absolute favorite things that we

2:02.8

have ever run on tablet magazine, a story that we ran a few years back on the Unorthodox

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Tablet Magazine, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Tablet Magazine and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.