meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The Prestige TV Podcast

'Love Story' Episodes 1-3: American Royal-Tea

The Prestige TV Podcast

The Ringer

Tv & Film

4.21.8K Ratings

🗓️ 16 February 2026

⏱️ 48 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Jo and Katey Rich tackle the Kennedys, Calvin Klein, the ’90s, and much more as they dissect the first three episodes of Ryan Murphy’s ‘Love Story.’ Email us! prestigetv@spotify.com Follow us on IG and TikTok! Subscribe to the Ringer TV YouTube channel here for full episodes of The Prestige TV Podcast and so much more! Intro (0:00) JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette memories (1:54) ‘The People vs. O.J. Simpson’ vibes (3:43) Too much Jackie O? (5:45) Royal family comparisons (8:13) Book connections (12:30) Inside the making of the show (16:09) The chemistry between Carolyn and JFK Jr. (18:10) Sarah Pidgeon as Carolyn (21:01) How do we feel about Paul Anthony Kelly? (21:45) Naomi Watts (24:00) The real meet-cute (28:09) Daryl Hannah (29:20) Is this show for the girls? (30:33) Revisiting the ’90s (32:08) Let’s talk about Calvin Klein (36:29) The internet reacts to the show’s fashion (37:53) We have to talk about the dog (39:57) The plane crash (42:40) Outro (47:47) Host: Joanna Robinson Guest: Katey Rich Producer: Devon Renaldo Additional Production Support: Justin Sayles Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hello, welcome back to the PrestiGTV podcast feed. I'm Joanna Robinson. Joining me today,

0:22.9

it's Katie Rich. Yay! Katie Rich is a longtime pal of mine, my first and best ever editor at Vanity Fair.

0:31.1

Thank you. Thank you for being here. I love recording podcasts with you. And for all the amount of time we've spent talking to each other into microphones, it's so rarely been in person. Like, what a thrill. I feel like twice ever. I mean, yesterday. Yeah, yesterday. But then in like a hotel room after the Oscars. In 2020. Yeah. In February 2020. And then after that, the force was too great. They had to separate us. Yeah, yeah. The whole pandemic happened. So here we go. We're making up for last time. But we are Vanity Fair Refugees and we are here to cover Love Story, the FX series that was once called American Love Story. Now just called Love Story. I think it's a good choice. I don't know. What do you think?

1:10.1

Like to distance it from the American blank blank story franchise. It can be its own thing a little bit, right? It's interesting to me. We're going to talk about the first three episodes because they dropped as like a little mini binge drop. So we're not going to dive deep into anything. We're not going to delve into details. We're just taking like a big picture look at this show as I guess a kind of

1:28.9

Valentine's Day special, the Presbytee TV podcast. We're here to talk about love story. So if you haven't

1:32.9

watched the first three episodes, go watch them and then and then watch or listen to this podcast.

1:38.2

And then also I will just say blanket spoiler warning for history. The 90s. It happened. Yeah. We might talk about it. So that is the plan today on the prestige feed. About this. First, I'm going to ask you this question. Before we get into like the show in general, what is your memory? You're just like a couple years younger than I am, but we were like alive and awake and active in the 90s. Yeah. What is your memory of JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bassett? Like what did you remember? I remember when they're playing crash. I was at the beach with my friends. Like that was the news. It was the same, like maybe the same week as Woodstock 99. If you can picture that, of like those being the headlines coming out. Right. And like just at the age where he's starting, you know, like paying attention to the news in that way. And I'm sure I knew who he was because that news was relevant. But I bet I knew nothing about Carolyn. Like I was not like a fashiony kind of teenager. I wouldn't have been reading like the New York Post, obviously. I wasn't anywhere in the New York area. So I don't think I had any awareness of

2:34.8

how that celebrity worked. I think that probably came around the time of working at Annie Fair,

2:39.1

editing fashion stories, like knowing her wedding dress is iconic, that kind of thing. And like

2:43.3

absorbing more Kennedy lore as I got older. But yeah, that period of New York early 90s,

2:48.5

I know mostly through like other people's stories, not this one.

2:51.2

My only memory of them is the wedding, like the wedding photos, her iconic dress. They got married

2:59.0

in like a barn somewhere, which will be covered. A church. An old African American church,

3:04.5

like, if they did that now, we would be like, guys, what's happening? Yeah. Why are we here? And so that, the, like, the photo of them leaving that church. Yes. That looks like a barn, but it's a church. Yes. It's like an old weather and seaside church. Yeah, weather, weather, weather church. Her dress, this very, like, we got married moment on the cover of People magazine and then the crash. And that's

3:25.8

really all. It's like the wedding and the crash. Absolutely. Yeah. And so for people who are

3:30.8

older than we are or more dialed in than we were at the time, this might be more relevant.

3:36.2

But I was thinking about this, you know, this is a Ryan Murphy joint, but what I have been given to understand

3:41.9

is that it's closer to the People v. O.J., American Crime Story in that it's Ryan Murphy with

3:48.1

Nina Jacobson and Brad Simpson, his like longtime partners, but this show is created by Connor

3:53.0

Hines. It's not really like a Ryan Murphy show. It's got his name on it, but it's not, he's not as involved as he has been in some of his other projects. Even with like the swans, like is this not a similar situation where it's like got a creator and it's got the Ryan Murphy umbrella, but the creator can do their own thing? I think it's like that, but I just, I think it's different from an American horror story or the beauty or these other things. So when you say Ryan Murphy, I feel like the Ryan Murphy brand means something specifically in a lot, like since OJ happened to now, the, there's been, I don't know, a dozen Ryan Murphy shows. I mean, OJ was 10 years ago.. Yeah, I remember we covered the heck out of that show together.

4:33.0

So I just, I remember, we definitely did.

4:34.9

But I just remember when I've been pitching this show to people, love story, get into it.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from The Ringer, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of The Ringer and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.