This is the Bible Book Club.

Welcome to the Club.

Welcome to a special edition of the Bible Book Club in which we are answering listener questions.

So a little departure from our typical content.

A big departure.

A big departure. But we ask and you guys delivered. We got so many questions. So a little departure from our typical content. A big departure. But we ask and you guys delivered. We got so many questions. We could not possibly answer them all. But we have chosen a lot of

the ones that are actually complicated and hard questions. Yeah. Some of them are really,

you asked great questions. Let me first say that. Yeah. And if we chose your question, you will be

getting a Bible book club sweatshirt. It will be delivered in the mail this month. Yeah, we'll get it out.

Let's start with a question from Rebecca. Rebecca asks, why do innocent people get punished for the

actions of someone else? Here are a few of the examples I'm thinking of. Deuteronomy 22, 28 through 29,

the law about a man being required to marry a woman if he rapes her. It doesn't sit right with me

that the women is now trapped with her rapist the rest of her life. Another example, numbers

1632. The men and their households got swallowed up. What did the wife and children do or not do to deserve that fate?

Final example, Joshua 7, the story of Aiken, sealing from Jericho, where both he and his sons and daughters are all stoned and punished.

Okay, this is a hotly debated, but important topic, and we could make it an entire episode. First, we have to look at the

context of the story. In the ancient near East and not just Israel, but in particular for much

of the Old Testament, a person was not seen so much as an individual, but as an inseparable

member of a family clan, a nation, totally different

from today. If someone, especially a clan leader, sinned, the entire group was affected by the

consequences. Sin was seen as contagious. So like if your leader had it, you probably had it.

The Israelites saw a sin committed

...