I'm handed this case and while I'm hesitant to ever characterize any murder case as a garden

variety murder, it's really what it looked like.

And there was never an inkling that this was going to turn into the case that it became.

I'm Scott Weinberger.

Investigator of Journalist and former Deputy Sheriff.

I'm Anna Segenic-Alazi, former New York City homicide prosecutor and host of investigation

discoveries through conviction.

And this is Anatomy of Murder.

Today's story takes place in Brooklyn, New York, where you may remember.

I was a prosecutor for many years and it was handled by colleagues who are also friends

of mine, but this is a case that no one working in our office will ever forget.

For this podcast, we spoke to two of the prosecutors that handled this.

The first was Stephen Murphy.

It's late summer of 2001 and within a highly dense residential area sits Willoughby Park.

In the summer, there's a group of kids in the neighborhood of Brooklyn fed for stivocent

and there's two brothers and these brothers are pivots in this case.

They are quarry and Dennis Brown.

Just to give you a little bit more about the two brothers, they were super close.

Dennis was the older of the two.

They were seen together all the time.

And they're not only brothers, but they look very much alike.

Now both of them had round faces.

...