It was so many pieces of the puzzle.

He stole their car and robbed them and put them in the trunk of the car and shot them.

There had been a fire and gold shorts and someone had died.

There were some city workers that came across in the middle of a pile of trash.

The decouposed body was in a tarp.

The body had no head, no hands, and no feet.

I'm Scott Weinberger, investigative journalist and former deputy sheriff.

I'm Anna Sige-Nikolazi, former New York City homicide prosecutor and host of investigation discoveries to conviction.

And this is an out of me of murder.

Before we get into the case, we have to go to the police station to see the police.

And this is an out of me of murder.

Before we get into today's case, we want to share one thing with you about us.

And that's what brought each of us to our professions.

When I was about five, my next door neighbor was a member of the NYPD.

And I remember him walking out of his house and he had this really incredibly looking uniform.

He had a long jacket, had about 50 buttons on it, it seemed like.

And it was always so impressive.

But it really didn't come until years later until I started really feeling like I was the type of person who would want to be there for someone in their worst of times.

The coming of journalists was just really an extension of that.

Getting the facts, holding people accountable, and taking that message far beyond the community that I was serving.

And for me, it was never that one thing.

What I can say is that I knew from my first semester of law school in my first week of criminal law class that that's exactly what I was going to do and that a prosecutor was exactly what I was going to be.

...