How does a very popular local private investigator end up dead?

Now this is a guy much loved in the community that knows everybody's deep dark secrets.

I mean when you're in a small town, small town, comparatively, and you know who's cheating on who?

What husband wants you to tell his wife and vice versa?

Who's paying somebody off? Who wants undercover surveillance?

You know it all. Did that have anything to do with the death of a 37 year old husband and dad?

And the prime of his life, as I mentioned, much loved in the community, Jim Capelo, Jr.

Crime stories with Nancy Grace

I'm Nancy Grace. This is Crime stories. Thank you for being with us here at Fox Nation and Sirius XM111.

First of all, take a listen to our friends at W-A-F-F-48. Liz Hurley.

Jim Capelo, Sr. and Jim Sister Jamie were driving to Huntsville from out of state to lead a search team to find Jim.

Jim's wife posted on Facebook that she had last spoken to him Thursday morning.

She asked for help looking for him Friday. Jim Sister spoke to him late Wednesday night.

11 o'clock, I had my way to work, my way to the car. I did call him.

And he answered and he was panicky, real panicky, anxious.

He couldn't get his words together. I text Nikki and asked her how his night was.

She said at one point, he woke up freezing and she warmed him up.

But after that, he slept well and he's doing well this morning.

I tried calling him twice that day and two separate occasions and he didn't answer.

Jamie is a nurse and she knew that her baby brother was suddenly and mysteriously very ill.

What do we know about his ailments? Joining me in All Star panel, Rachel Hammers, crime online.com investigative reporter, joining us there in Huntsville.

Jennifer Shen Forensic Pathologist, former director of the San Diego Police Department crime lab.

...