There was a reason why things happen the way they happen.

It was the reason why that day I got a phone call from a girl who I was dealing with in another case,

maybe the stars or, but there was the reason why I got that phone call that day. I'm Scott Weinberger, investigative journalist and former deputy sheriff.

I'm Anaseika Nicholazzi, former New York City homicide prosecutor and host of

investigation discoveries true conviction.

And this is anatomy of murder.

There's something particularly haunting about a case where a person disappears without a trace, especially in a tight-knit community.

The lack of answers, the feeling of not knowing what happened, it leaves an open wound for the family and the community.

Today's case is an example of that anguish.

It's the story of a 21-year-old woman

who seemed to vanish into thin air

one summer night in 2011. but what started as a missing person's case

would evolve into something much darker and it would take over a decade to get

answers.

This investigation not only spans years, but crosses state lines and involves multiple law

enforcement agencies.

But it may never have been solved if not for the work of investigator Paul Newton and

criminalist Ali Weissman.

And because of that, we wanted you to hear what they both had to say.

Here's Paul Newton who from the time he was a child new law enforcement would be his path

At the age of five I always wanted to be a deputy sheriff I never let go that dream if want to be a Butler County deputy sheriff

He followed his dream and spent about 25 years as a Deputy Sheriff in Butler County, Ohio.

...