meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The Patrick Madrid Show

"Is it Wrong to Feel Sympathy for Innocent Palestinians?" (Special Podcast Highlight)

The Patrick Madrid Show

Relevant Radio

Religion & Spirituality, Christianity

4.8587 Ratings

🗓️ 2 May 2024

⏱️ 16 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Sometimes, what's going on in our world can bring out the worst in people. How can we as Catholics be people of peace and hope?

 

A listener named Christine from Detroit shares her deep feelings of sympathy and distress over the suffering of innocent Palestinians amidst the conflicts in Israel. She questions whether it’s wrong as a Catholic to feel anger and sympathy towards these injustices, particularly the impact on children.

 

Patrick Madrid reassures Christine that feeling sympathy towards innocent Palestinians is not only appropriate but a reflection of our Christian duty to empathize with the suffering. He emphasizes that such feelings align perfectly with our values, particularly the call to recognize the dignity and worth of every human life, irrespective of one’s background or nationality.

 

Patrick also shares his personal experiences, which have led him to form a significant connection with Palestinian communities, noting his interactions have primarily been with Palestinians, both Christian and Muslim. It's not black and white all the time. He highlights the complexity of the situation—condemning the actions of Hamas and other extremists while also criticizing any actions by the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) that harm innocent lives.

 

Importantly, Patrick navigates the delicate balance of supporting Israel’s right to exist and defend itself, while also advocating for the fundamental rights and protections of Palestinian civilians caught in the crossfire. He calls out the misguided activism of some, particularly on college campuses, who may not fully grasp the complexities of the conflict or may be driven by extremist ideologies rather than a genuine concern for human rights.

 

What can Catholics do? Reflecting on Patrick's insights, Catholics are encouraged to maintain a balanced perspective, informed by a commitment to peace and justice. This includes praying for all affected, advocating for peaceful solutions, and educating oneself on the realities of the conflict to avoid being swayed by biased narratives. It’s about holding fast to a hope for peace, supporting efforts that respect the dignity of all involved, and prayerfully standing in solidarity with those who suffer, all while seeking wisdom and guidance on how to effectively contribute to a resolution.

 

Christine's heartfelt concern and Patrick Madrid’s thoughtful response show a powerful message: In the face of conflict, Catholics are called to a profound empathy that transcends borders, informed by a deep faith and commitment to the teachings of Jesus Christ. Let us carry this message in our hearts and let it guide our actions towards peace and justice.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

I'm not here to debate anything. I'm just telling you my feelings.

0:04.5

Let's go to Christine now in Detroit. Hi, Christine.

0:08.2

Hi. Okay, so my question is, as a Catholic, is it wrong to feel sympathy and kind of anger at what's going on in Palestine, particularly with all the children

0:25.7

that are being killed. To be fair, I am Middle Eastern. So I have probably a different look on

0:33.2

things being that my history might not necessarily be your history. We know that there's been a long-standing

0:39.6

issue in that land. You know, I'm not anti-Semitic by any sense of the word, but it just seems like

0:45.7

if you try to say, you know, I'm feeling anger about what's going on or I'm feeling sympathy,

0:50.4

I mean, even these student protesters, well while I want them to definitely remain peaceful,

0:56.2

I can't say that I would for sure be upset if my children were old enough to be in solidarity

1:01.5

with them saying that, hey, you know, this needs to stop. But I don't know if I'm in the wrong

1:06.8

in saying that or in not having this commitment to Israel and saying, like, no, I support

1:13.9

everything that are doing 100%, even just from like a Christian perspective, because it seems

1:18.9

like they're Christians, not Catholic, but Christians that seem to have this unwavering support

1:24.8

for Israel, and they use biblical text. and I've talked to priests about this and

1:29.6

I would just really love to hear what you have to say about about this. Yeah, thanks for the

1:35.7

opportunity to discuss it. So I'll offer you a series of different thoughts on this issue and

1:41.8

then I'd like to know what you think about my thoughts on

1:44.4

this issue. Okay. So to get to your first question, is it wrong to feel sympathy? No, not at all.

1:50.2

I share your sympathy and empathy for the people, the innocent people who are being harmed

1:55.5

by the bombings and the missiles and the bullets and the tanks and all that kind of thing. I don't think

2:02.0

sympathy is a strong enough word for how you and I feel about this, and you even more so perhaps,

2:06.8

just because these members are family. If you're an Arab and if your family is from this area,

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Relevant Radio, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Relevant Radio and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.