Inbox Question | A Better Approach to the S&P 500?
Big Picture Retirement®
Devin Carroll
4.7 • 545 Ratings
🗓️ 20 March 2025
⏱️ 8 minutes
🧾️ Download transcript
Summary
John asks about buying the individual sectors of the S&P 500 and rebalancing based on performance instead of simply buying an index fund. Devin shares the pros and cons that he can see with this strategy and shares what he thinks is a better approach.
Although this show does not provide specific tax, legal, or financial advice, you can engage Devin or John through their individual firms.
📍Contact Devin's team at https://carrolladvisory.co/podcast1
📍Contact John's team at https://www.rossandshoalmire.com/
If you're thinking, "I love the Big Picture Retirement podcast!" please consider rating and reviewing this show! This helps us support more people -- just like you -- move toward a confident retirement. Just scroll down to the "ratings and reviews" section, tap to rate with five stars, and select "Write a Review." Then be sure to let us know what you loved most about the episode!
Also, if you haven't done so already, follow the podcast. We add new content every week, and if you're not following, you'll likely miss out. Follow now!
Don't miss the Big Picture Retirement Planning Cheat Sheet. We've distilled the essential brackets, thresholds, and rules of retirement into an easy-to-digest, three-page summary. https://www.carrolladvisory.com/pl/2148282517
Want to ask Devin or John your question? Just visit https://www.bigpictureretirement.com/ and click on the "Ask A Question" menu selection.
Transcript
Click on a timestamp to play from that location
| 0:00.0 | Welcome to the Big Picture Retirement Show. |
| 0:07.7 | Today, we're going to the inbox to answer questions sent in by you, our listeners. |
| 0:12.3 | Now, if you'd like to send us a question, just head over to big pictureretirement.com and click the Ask a Question tab in the top menu. |
| 0:18.9 | Oh, and just a quick reminder. |
| 0:19.9 | On this podcast, we provide |
| 0:22.0 | general information and not specific tax, legal, or financial advice. But if you're ever ready |
| 0:28.3 | to move from the broad education we provide here to personalized advice that's specific to you, |
| 0:34.7 | you can find links to our websites down in the description. Now let's jump in |
| 0:39.1 | to today's question. Today's question comes from John. John said that I know that I don't know |
| 0:51.4 | what I don't know. John, that's an astute statement. Anyway, he goes on to say, |
| 0:56.7 | that being said, what am I missing with this distribution strategy? With DIYers, there's a love |
| 1:02.8 | affair with the S&P 500 and also with dollar cost averaging. That being said, if you had X amount of |
| 1:09.2 | money in the S&P 500, divided unequally in the 11 sectors, |
| 1:14.4 | and took distributions from the winners and rebalanced each year, preferably quarterly, |
| 1:21.0 | what are the pros and kinds? It seems simple enough. What am I missing as I've never heard of this strategy? |
| 1:28.8 | John, I do think there's some merit to this. Let me just think about this off the top of my head and go down some of the |
| 1:35.4 | pros here. So I think one, you know, you're only selling from the strongest performing |
| 1:41.2 | sectors of the economy. And that's a good way to lock in gains and avoid |
| 1:45.6 | selling into weakness, which I suppose would help reduce some of the risk associated with the |
| 1:51.1 | sequence of returns. I guess the second thing is this naturally creates a form of sector rotation |
| 1:58.0 | where you're trimming from what's hot and you're letting underperforming |
| 2:02.2 | assets recover. So in some ways, it's like momentum investing, except you're selling what's got |
... |
Please login to see the full transcript.
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Devin Carroll, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.
Generated transcripts are the property of Devin Carroll and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.
Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.

