meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Super Carlin Brothers

Harry Potter: An Absolutely SCATHING Review of the Order of the Phoenix

Super Carlin Brothers

J and Ben Carlin

News, Tv & Film, Entertainment News

4.81K Ratings

🗓️ 14 November 2025

⏱️ 21 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Head on over to http://uncommongoods.com/supercarlin to get 15% off! J breaks down EXACTLY why the Order is such a dysfunctional disaster of a secret society, why their mistakes matter, and how an extracurricular student club ends up outperforming them in every measurable way. From losing both Wizarding Wars, to missing obvious clues, to wasting their greatest assets (TONKS!!), to forcing a teenage boy to run an illegal, underground Defense club—this organization fumbles the bag spectacularly at every turn. Let’s dive into the most savage performance review Hogwarts has ever seen. #HarryPotter #SuperCarlinBrothers  Written by: J & Ben Carlin Edited by: Ethan Edghill 🎟️ Through the Griffin Door LIVE Tour — Southwest 2025 https://supercarlinbrothers.com/events/  Southwest Tour Dates:  3/07: Denver, CO - Chapter 33: Fight and Flight 3/09: Salt Lake City, UT - Chapter 34: The Dept of Mysteries 3/11: Las Vegas, NV - Chapter 35: Beyond the Veil 3/12: Phoenix, AZ- Chapter 36: The Only One He Ever Feared 3/14: Houston, TX - Chapter 37: The Lost Prophecy 3/15: Dallas, TX - Chapter 38: The Second War Begins

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

The Order of the Phoenix is terrible at their jobs.

0:03.6

Hey, brother!

0:04.5

Y'all, I hate to say it, but the Order of the Phoenix is darn near utterly useless, the organization,

0:11.0

that is, not the physical tome.

0:13.0

Although, on that note, it is the longest book in the series and centers around Voldemort

0:17.4

searching for a weapon, which is definitely not a weapon, but the prophecy, which he's already heard half of, and the other half, if he did hear, it wouldn't make him any more powerful. Like, it might have been useful if he heard it the first time around, but at this point, he's already marked the person. He said he shouldn't have marked, so like, but anyway, back to the Order of the Phoenix. One of the coolest moments in the whole series, dare I say, even in the films, is when

0:39.7

the order arrives at the Department of Mystery is looking like freaking angels and Sirius

0:44.3

is all.

0:45.3

Get away from my gun, son.

0:47.3

Boom, what a distilupt.

0:50.3

Being struck in such a distinctly non-magical way.

0:53.3

Like, Sirius really knows exactly how to get under his skin.

0:57.0

I love it.

0:58.0

But the Order of the Phoenix, whilst aligned with all of our own ideals and distinctly

1:03.0

positioned against the dark magic regime of Baltimore and the Death-Eaters,

1:07.0

are nothing shy of miserable at their jobs.

1:11.7

And I'm talking about both iterations of the order.

1:14.9

I mean, everyone we see in Moody's original photograph of the organization and the more

1:19.7

modern version that Harry meets in book five.

1:22.3

Collectively, they successfully lose both wars.

1:25.9

And I mean, like, granted, the first time they're acting in a very you know reactionary role to the rising threat of Voldemort but in round two what are you doing you had like an 11 year head start that is tremendous you know the moment

1:39.3

Voldemort comes back and half of Baltimore's army is in prison These are advantages they assure Harry are going to make a huge difference in the fight, but

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from J and Ben Carlin, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of J and Ben Carlin and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.