Giants at No. 5: Draft Strategy, Positional Value & Big Bets

Evan & Tiki

Audacy

Sports

4.2 • 988 Ratings

🗓️ 17 March 2026

⏱️ 20 minutes

🔗️ Recording | iTunes | RSS

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

The debate around the Giants’ No. 5 pick takes center stage as the crew dives into draft strategy, positional value, and what betting odds reveal about the team’s possible direction. With names like Sonny Styles, Caleb Downs, and Jeremiah Love in the mix, the conversation explores whether taking a running back or safety that high is bold strategy or risky misstep. Along the way, the discussion expands into bigger questions about how teams should evaluate draft success, the evolving value of the running back position, and whether Super Bowl outcomes should define decision-making. Plus, a major trade involving Jaylen Waddle shakes things up, adding another layer to the offseason landscape and sparking reactions about team-building philosophies across the league.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0	There's been a heavy debate about picking running backs early, should the Giants consider it with Jeremiah Love.
0:05.8	And I was very curious this morning about what the betting odds say.
0:08.8	So I saw that.
0:09.8	Obviously, Fernando Mendoza is overwhelming, overwhelming, overwhelming favorite to go number one overall to the Las Vegas Raiders.
0:16.8	And a considerable favorite for the Jets is Arvel Reese, which is not a surprise.
0:20.7	No, it makes perfect sense. They need edge rushers. Arvel Reese, which is not a surprise.
0:21.8	No, it makes perfect sense.
0:22.7	They need edge rushers.
0:22.9	Yep.
0:23.6	They traded.
0:24.7	There's a way.
0:27.2	So, I mean, obviously, they need defense.
0:27.5	Yeah.
0:30.4	That's where Aaron Glenn seems to be focusing this offseason.
0:31.0	No doubt.
0:31.6	And they need to.
0:34.1	Because, I mean, they're basically rebuilding the defense from scratch.
0:34.4	Right. But I was curious about number five. So let's go to our Sean Morash. I'm going to
0:40.9	try to give you information without putting my opinion in desk where he will reveal to us the
0:46.1	betting odds on who the Giants will take at number five. Well, Evan, this fan focus is sponsored by
0:51.2	Chef IQ, Precision Cooking, Effortless Results, Chef IQ.com. Yes, the betting odds are out for the number five pick in the draft. Remember, though, when betting on this, it's who gets taken number five. Correct. That's a move out. Correct. That's important to note. Sunny Stiles is the favorite at plus 190, the lineback from Ohio State. Caleb Downs is the second favorite at plus 265, the safety from Ohio State. Your third favorite, Jeremiah Love at plus 425, which is only a smart bet if the Giants trade out. And of course, Francis Mauiago, the offensive lineman, if I'm saying that right now, I've screwed it up. Plus 850 is the fourth favorite. So think about this for a second. Also, Evan, this fan focus was sponsored by Town Fair Tire. Nobody beats Town Fair Tire, nobody.
1:28.7	And those are betting odds that tell you that they really don't know. Because no one's minus. Everyone's kind of... Right. They have no idea. They don't know. Obviously, how the Draft Board Falls will have a big part of it. If the Giants trade out, who trades up, we'll have a big part of it. But two of the top three guys with the betting odd favorites to go number five are positions
	...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Previous episode | Next episode

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Audacy, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Audacy and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.