meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The Gray Area with Sean Illing

Frances Lee on why bipartisanship is irrational

The Gray Area with Sean Illing

Vox Media Podcast Network

Politics, News, News Commentary, Philosophy, Society & Culture

4.511.1K Ratings

🗓️ 21 January 2019

⏱️ 59 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

There aren’t too many people with an idea that will actually change how you think about American politics. But Frances Lee is one of them. In her new book, Insecure Majorities, Lee makes a point that sounds strange when you hear it, but changes everything once you understand it. For most of American history, American politics has been under one-party rule. For decades, that party was the Republican Party. Then, for decades more, it was the Democratic Party. It’s only been in the past few decades that control of Congress has begun flipping back every few years, that presidential elections have become routinely decided by a few percentage points, that both parties are always this close to gaining or losing the majority. That kind of close competition, Lee shows, makes the daily compromises of bipartisan governance literally irrational. And politicians know it. Lee’s got the receipts. "Confrontation fits our strategy,” Dick Cheney once said. "Polarization often has very beneficial results. If everything is handled through compromise and conciliation, if there are no real issues dividing us from the Democrats, why should the country change and make us the majority?” Why indeed? This is a conversation about that question, about how the system we have incentivizes a politics of confrontation we don’t seem to want and makes steady, stable governance a thing of the past. Book Recommendations: The Imprint of Congress by David R. Mayhew Fear Itself: The New Deal and the Origins of Our Time by Ira Katznelson Congress's Constitution: Legislative Authority and the Separation of Powers by Josh Chafetz Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

When you drive a Chevy electric vehicle, you're getting more than a way to get from point A to point B.

0:06.0

You're saying goodbye to gas stations and how low to open roads.

0:09.0

With the growing network of public charging stations, you'll be able to charge your EV while you shop, work, or do whatever you want to be doing with your time.

0:17.0

Chevy is making EVs for everyone, everywhere. Go to chevrelay.com slash electric to learn more.

0:24.0

If an issue comes to be seen as associated with a president, such that that president's performance in office is benchmarked against their ability to resolve that issue, then that sets off that political incentive on the opposing party, which is we can't give the president a win.

0:55.0

Hello, welcome to Mr. Clanchon, the Vox Media Podcast Network. A quick request before we start up today. I'm looking for some good interview ideas on polarization, political identity.

1:07.0

Anybody you'd be interested in hearing on those issues on the show doesn't need to be academics or writers or analysts of it.

1:14.0

Could be somebody you think increases polarization in our polity. Could be somebody you think reduces it.

1:20.0

I'm trying to think through that as I think through the end of my book and often you all have better guest ideas that I do.

1:26.0

So my email is as recline show at Vox.com again as recline show at Vox.com. If you've got some weird ideas there or just some good ideas there, please email me.

1:35.0

My guest today is someone I really wanted to have on around the dawn of a new Congress because her work has influenced me tremendously in how I think about divided government in particular, but Congress and its relationship with the presidency in general is, Francis Lee.

1:50.0

She's a political scientist at the University of Maryland. She just wrote a fascinating new book called insecure majorities, Congress and the perpetual campaign. Her book before that, which is called Beyond Ideology,

2:01.0

is one of like the three or five political science books I recommend most often. And what she's showing in in this new book is that we're in a period that is genuinely different from what most periods in American political life have been like.

2:16.0

We're in a period of competition where control of Congress and the presidency is changing hands constantly where landsides almost never happen.

2:25.0

Certainly presidential landsides have seemed to have stopped happening. We don't have outcomes like we had say in 1984 anymore.

2:32.0

Nobody is quite sure why, but her book is looking at how an era of intense constant competition, how an era where every party is constantly a potential majority and minority, how that changes political behavior.

2:46.0

And I think she makes a very convincing case that it changes it profoundly that this period of competition is behind a lot of what has changed in American politics in a way that we don't always know how to integrate into our models or integrate into our thinking.

3:00.0

It seems like competition is always the order of the day, but it really hasn't been. And I think it's incredible explanatory power here.

3:08.0

And I think it's very tactically important for understanding why Democrats in Congress are going to act like they will in the next couple of years,

3:15.0

my Republicans are going to act like they will in the next couple of years. And also how Donald Trump both will act and should act and could act.

3:22.0

And maybe what he doesn't quite understand about presidential rhetoric and leadership in an era of divided highly competitive government.

3:30.0

This is a very, very helpful episode here is Francis Lee.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Vox Media Podcast Network, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Vox Media Podcast Network and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.