meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Renaissance English History Podcast: A Show About the Tudors

Forget the Deathbed Myth: Tracy Borman on Elizabeth I, James VI, and The Stolen Crown

Renaissance English History Podcast: A Show About the Tudors

Heather Teysko

History

4.6624 Ratings

🗓️ 18 November 2025

⏱️ 29 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Did Elizabeth I actually name James VI of Scotland as her heir? Historian Dr. Tracy Borman joins me to talk about her new book, The Stolen Crown, and the newly uncovered evidence showing that the deathbed scene we’ve all heard was rewritten after the fact. We talk about the real contenders for the throne, the political panic around Elizabeth’s refusal to name an heir, Robert Cecil’s king-making, James’s shaky reputation in England, and why the 1603 succession was anything but inevitable. Tracy Borman is Chief Historian for Historic Royal Palaces and the author of numerous Tudor histories. The Stolen Crown is out now. Order it on Amazon or your favorite bookstore! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hey, friend, I'm really excited to share this conversation with Dr. Tracy Borman about her brand

0:07.4

new book, The Stolen Crown, which really kind of completely upends that neat little story

0:13.1

that we've all heard about Elizabeth I, calmly naming James I of Scotland as her heir on

0:20.0

her deathbed. As Tracy explains in this conversation

0:23.8

that tidy scene was actually crafted after the fact, once James was safely on the throne and

0:30.4

really needed some good PR. A newly examined manuscript of William Camden's history of Elizabeth's reign shows that he originally

0:39.6

wrote that Elizabeth died without naming anyone at all, and only later rewrote the deathbed

0:45.8

scene under pressure from James himself. Once you know that, the succession in 1603 stops looking

0:53.0

like a smooth handover and starts looking like what it really was,

0:57.2

which was a fierce race for the crown that actually several people could realistically have won.

1:03.6

So in our conversation, Tracy walks us through all of the rival claimants who were circling around Elizabeth's throne throughout her reign.

1:12.1

Of course, some of them are famous, Mary Queen of Scots, the Grey Sisters, Henry Hastings, Margaret Stanley, and her son

1:18.4

Ferdinando, I love that name, are Bella Stewart and even the Infanta Isabella of Spain.

1:26.8

And we kind of talked about all of these different claimants and

1:30.6

Elizabeth's absolute refusal to name and air and how that caused decades of anxiety and how

1:37.5

figures like Peter Wentworth and Shakespeare and Robert Cecil pushed and plotted and argued

1:43.8

over what should happen after the

1:46.0

queen died. So really excited to bring you this conversation with Tracy Borman. Definitely check out

1:50.7

her book, The Stolen Crown. I'll put a link in the comments below. She is absolutely

1:55.8

fabulous, one of my most favorite historians and people. Just a real joy and delight to chat with her and really

2:04.5

excited to share this conversation with you. So we will just get directly into it. So you have

2:08.6

this new book out, The Stolen Crown, about how James I wasn't the obvious given choice. Yeah,

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Heather Teysko, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Heather Teysko and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.