meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Police Off The Cuff/Real Crime Stories

FBI Profiler Jim Clemente, is he ever wrong about his profiles.

Police Off The Cuff/Real Crime Stories

Bill Cannon Police off the Cuff/Real Crime Stories

Law Enforcement, Crime, True Crime, Military

4.4870 Ratings

🗓️ 5 May 2026

⏱️ 17 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

FBI Profiler Jim Clemente, is he ever wrong about his profiles?  Former FBI profiler Jim Clemente joins the conversation as we examine his theory in the Nancy Guthrie case and what the offender’s behavior may reveal. We break down the evidence, the masked suspect, and whether this kidnapping points to one offender or something more complex. This episode of Police Off the Cuff takes a hard look at the profiler’s theory, the crime scene, and the questions investigators still need to answer.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

All right, Jim Clementi, we will continue to follow this case until hopefully.

0:05.0

So, you know, very, very interesting.

0:06.9

But then again, when he just says right there, she was alive up into the point, basically a front step.

0:14.5

And so if she died or was helpless at that point, that sort of gives more credence to the more than one kidnapper theory

0:23.6

that we have. And again, Jim Clementi, when I read his profile of Rex Eumann that was 12 years,

0:34.6

was written 12 years before Rex Eumann was arrested, it was almost exactly years before Rex Newman was arrested. It was almost exactly

0:39.3

who Rex Newman was. It was brilliant. So I have tremendous respect for him. And as I said,

0:46.2

Jim Clemente has been on this show probably four or five times. And we love the guy. And I,

0:52.6

but even though I'm going to, I'm going to disagree with them.

0:55.6

You know, I was a homicide sergeant. Manhattan North, I went to hundreds and hundreds of

0:59.7

homicide shootings, robberies, sex crimes, all kinds of crime scenes. And we got some experience

1:06.4

here too. Maybe we're not trained in behavioral analysis, BAU, the behavioral analysis unit with the FBI,

1:13.4

but you come up with some skills in making hypotheses on these cases through working numerous cases,

1:22.9

Phil. Yeah, listen, let's face it. Profiling is advisory and not determinative.

1:28.5

Cases are solved by evidence and not theory. Now, with that said, I agree with a lot of what

1:33.4

Jim Clementi stated there specifically about the blood. I couldn't agree more. I think he's right

1:38.2

on track with that. And I think he's on to something when he says that he believes it could

1:43.5

be something directed at Savannah Guthrie.

1:46.5

And only because we're so far into the investigation, we're 87 days in, I'm going to back

1:52.2

off of that theory because that's one of the theories that would jump right out at me right

1:56.4

from the jump.

1:57.4

And I would think that FBI and the local police, the investigators on the case,

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Bill Cannon Police off the Cuff/Real Crime Stories, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Bill Cannon Police off the Cuff/Real Crime Stories and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.