Prime members, you can listen to Redhanded early and ad-free on Amazon Music. Download the app today.

If you love True Crime, the Generation Y Podcast is essential listening. Hosts Aaron and Justin started this podcast over 10 years ago to dissect together some of the craziest and most notable murders, crimes and conspiracy theories.

And with over 450 episodes, there's a little something for every True Crime lover. Follow the Generation Y Podcast wherever you listen to podcasts.

I'm Sruti. I'm Hannah. And welcome to Redhanded. Yes. Welcome. Come on in. The water's horrible. It's fucking covered in algae or something equally horrible.

But we are here and we are ready to get started with quite a tale.

The noise you just heard was Mabel's Tale bashing against a metal pole. But now she's gone to bed so it's all going to be fine.

So in 2013, a bizarre story hit headlines across the world. An American family who had adopted a six-year-old girl from Ukraine had suddenly abandoned her in an apartment in Fayetteville, Indiana and run off to Canada.

The couple, Michael and Christine Barnett, claimed the Natalia Grace, a child with diastrophic dysplasia, a rare form of dwarfism, was not in fact a little girl.

But a fully grown 22-year-old woman who had been trying to kill their entire family.

There really is no subtle way to start this story with a plotline like that. And with comparisons to the 2009 horror movie, often, they came out just a year before the Barnett's adopted Natalia.

Believe me, this case is as fucking weird as it gets.

I didn't realise that this was after all.

Oh yes, a year after. That's bananas.

So to really understand just how bananas it all is, we're going to have to start the beginning.

Michael and Christine Barnett, plus their three sons, 11-year-old Jake, nine-year-old Wesley, and six-year-old Ethan, with a picture perfect family.

And I can't say the word Wesley without thinking about Wesley's types arms.

Now we're all thinking about it, so you're welcome.

Why would you name your son Wesley's never going to have arms as good as Wesley's name?

Something to aspire to.

True, maybe we all be more Wesley's like...

Every day is Arms Day when your name is Wesley.

Well, I'm going to have to start doing some serious arms days because I've got to wear a bloody strapless bridesmaid dress in September.

...