meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Mill House Podcast

Episode 139: Capt. Eric Herstedt - The Straight Shooter

Mill House Podcast

Mill House

Leisure, Wilderness, Education, Hobbies, Sports

4.9 • 1.1K Ratings

🗓️ 21 May 2025

⏱️ 100 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Capt. Eric Herstedt is a seasoned and versatile fishing guide based in Everglades National Park and the Florida Keys, specializing in light tackle and fly fishing. Whether it’s spin, bait, plug, artificial, or fly—Eric does it all, and he does it with the best of them. With decades of experience and an unmatched passion for the water, Eric has built a reputation as a top-tier guide known for his skill, adaptability, and commitment to providing unforgettable days on the water.Born in Miami and raised on Long Key in the heart of the Florida Keys, Eric developed a deep connection to the outdoors and the rich fishing grounds surrounding him. By the age of 3, he was already casting a spin rod, and at just 14 years old, he achieved his first Flats Grand Slam—landing a bonefish, permit, and tarpon in a single day. Though spin and plug fishing were his early go-tos, Eric discovered fly fishing at age 9 and quickly embraced its challenges and rewards.Eric’s talent and dedication have made him a fixture in the tournament scene. He and Nicky fished the Golden Fly Tarpon Tournament together for nine consecutive years, narrowly missing a victory a couple of times. In 2022, Eric and angler Mike Criscola finished as runners-up in the legendary Gold Cup Tarpon Tournament—further proof of Eric’s consistency and sharp instincts under pressure.Beyond the tournaments, Eric has contributed to conservation efforts with Bonefish & Tarpon Trust (BTT), working alongside Capt. Doug Kilpatrick and Dr. Ross Boucek to help establish best practices for handling bonefish safely at the boat.Eric is known not only for his skills on the water but also for his honesty and authenticity—he’s a straight shooter who tells it like it is. Whether you’re chasing tarpon on fly or just getting your feet wet, Eric is the kind of guide who makes the day memorable.We hope you enjoy getting to know Capt. Eric Herstedt as much as we have.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Starting from a 90-year-old family recipe, wickles are wickedly delicious pickles packed with garlic and peppers, a staple in our skiff in all shoreline lunches.

0:12.7

Originating from Sim's grandmother's kitchen to a pantry near yours.

0:17.1

From pickles, okra, relishes, and spreads, check them out to elevate all of your meals to the next level.

0:29.4

Whether on the boat, on the river, or in the woods, Yeti products are by our side.

0:35.6

There are many innovative first-class companies in the outdoor market today, but none more so than Yeti.

0:42.3

In 2006, they took the industry by storm, when they produced their first rotomolded cooler that was reliable and built for the wild.

0:51.3

17 years later, with a multitude of new products, they continue to raise the bar and be the

0:57.7

gold standard for all outdoor brands.

1:00.8

We couldn't be more proud to have them as a millhouse sponsor and a family member.

1:19.6

We broke everything, we broke lines, we broke hooks, we broke rods, we broke our minds, we broke marriages, we broke the whole thing. We came up with the idea of going out that night

1:26.6

and chasing girls and whoever had the biggest pair of panties went to pot.

1:30.8

I knocked another arrow and he turned around the other way and I shot him going through the other way.

1:35.2

So I double lunged him both ways.

1:37.9

But it was nothing for us to paddle an air mattress out into government cut.

1:42.6

I got him on. All right now.

1:44.9

We're going to teach him a lesson.

1:47.7

I'm just an old guy that likes to fish.

1:49.5

I'm not quitting yet.

1:51.9

And he said, well, who the hell do you think you are, Sue App?

1:55.1

And I said, that's exactly who I am.

1:58.6

Life's journey to the grave should not be one arriving with a pretty well-preserved body,

2:03.6

but rather skid in broadside in a cloud of smoke, thoroughly torn out, thoroughly used up, proclaiming wildly.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Mill House, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Mill House and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.