Ep. 159: The Anti-Worker Pseudo-psychology of Corporate Personality Testing

Citations Needed

Bias, News, Media, Society & Culture, Journalism, Criticism, Politics

4.8 • 4K Ratings

🗓️ 27 April 2022

⏱️ 63 minutes

🔗️ Recording | iTunes | RSS

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

"Is it a higher compliment to be called a) a person of real feeling, or b) a consistently reasonable person?" "Are you more successful at a) following a carefully worked-out plan, or b) dealing with the unexpected and seeing quickly what should have been done?" "Which word in each pair appeals to you more? a) scheduled, or b) unplanned?"

Questions like these are posed to millions of current and prospective workers and students every year. They come from personality tests, whether the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator, Clifton StrengthsFinder, or other surveys purporting to assess personality traits and job aptitude. Through a series of tens to hundreds of questions, personality inventories claim to identify qualities like dominance, neuroticism, or introversion, synthesize a user profile, and determine that user’s fitness for a given job.

But beneath this ostensibly neutral goal of matching a person with their ideal form of employment lies a much more sinister aim: Identifying and weeding out would-be dissenters, labor organizers, and union sympathizers. Additionally, studies have shown repeatedly that commercial personality tests like the commonly used Myers-Briggs have little to no scientific value. Why, then, does their use continue–with anywhere from 60 to 80% of prospective workers taking a personality test–and given their anti-labor history, what harms do they pose?

On this episode, we examine the history of personality testing used in military, educational, and corporate settings; the relationship between personality assessments, labor law, and the corporate consultancy class; how personality testing threatens the livelihoods of people based on race, disability, and other factors; and media’s role in laundering tests as benign instruments of self-realization.

Our guest is writer Liza Featherstone.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0	This is Citations Needed with Nemeshirazi and Adam Johnson.
0:09.0	Welcome to Citations Needed, a podcast on the media, power, PR and the history of Bullshit
0:14.6	I am Nemeshirazi.
0:16.1	You can follow the show on Twitter at CitationsPod, Facebook, Citations Needed and become
0:21.6	a supporter of the show through patreon.com slash Citations Needed Podcast, all your support
0:27.3	through patreon is incredibly appreciated as we are 100% listener funded.
0:32.0	That's true, we don't do ads, which is very unusual.
0:35.4	So if you can, please support us through patreon.
0:37.4	It does help keep the episodes themselves free and if you sign up there, you get access
0:41.0	to many episode news briefs, AMAs, newsletters and other little goodies.
0:45.6	So if you can, please help us out there and help keep the show sustainable.
0:53.3	Is it a higher compliment to be called A, a person of real feeling or B, a consistently
1:01.6	reasonable person?
1:04.0	Are you more successful at A, following a carefully worked out plan or B, dealing with
1:11.8	the unexpected and seeing quickly what should have been done?
1:16.4	Which word in each pair appeals to you more?
1:24.9	Questions like these are posed to millions of current and prospective workers and students
1:28.9	every year.
1:30.2	They come from personality tests, whether the Myers-Briggs type indicator, Clifton Strengths
1:34.8	Finder or other surveys reporting to assess personality traits and job aptitude.
1:39.6	Through a series of tens to hundreds of questions, personality, inventories claim to identify
1:43.5	qualities like dominance, neuroticism or introversion, synthesize a user's profile and determine
	...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Previous episode | Next episode

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Citations Needed, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Citations Needed and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.