4.2 • 970 Ratings
🗓️ 8 November 2023
⏱️ 58 minutes
🧾️ Download transcript
The arcane numbering system is gone, but Sean and Varn have (surprise!) a new miniseries. Inspired by current events - such as the Russo-Ukrainian War, Israel's ongoing atrocities in Gaza, and the turn towards post-neoliberal economic nationalism - we're going to explore all manner of Marxist and non-Marxist theories on the nation state to help get our heads around the current mess the world is in and hopefully chart a pathway out.
How did the nation-state rise in the early modern world? what role has nationalism played in capitalist development? What are the historical legacies of Lenin and Stalin's nationalities policies? Rhetoric aside, what is the relationship (if any) between national liberation movements and the communist project?
This is an extended preview. For access to the entire episode, become a patron today at www.patreon.com/theantifada. To see the video recording of this episode and get all of C. Derick Varn's amazing content, subscribe at www.patreon.com/varnvlog
For this first episode we mention various theorists - Harun Yilnaz, Ze'ev Sternhell, Benedict Anderson, Benjamin Studebaker, Eric Hobsbawm - and also look at this essay: https://www.marxists.org/history/etol/newspape/atc/3587.html
Click on a timestamp to play from that location
0:00.0 | Welcome to diving into the record where we finally give up the number system for now a topic system episode. |
0:20.0 | Or we can just get weird and make it like a Roman numeral system with maybe like dot A dot B dot C said or something like that |
0:29.8 | Just go full prints on it. Nonetheless, this is part one of a series on nationalism's plural, |
0:40.0 | both methodological and otherwise, although I don't know today, originally we were going to talk about methodological nationalism and I realized like, well, fuck, we have to talk about what nationalism is and like the national question and all the bizarre ass ways that this has tied Marxism and anarchism into a goddamn not for most of its history I think these are the |
1:09.8 | questions interestingly that Marx and Ingalls themselves are the least consistent on and the ones that we |
1:17.8 | actually have the most activism on and I think I'm gonna you know one of the reasons why I wanted to talk |
1:25.0 | about methodological nationalism beyond just nationalism to court is that some of |
1:31.2 | this is methodological but some of this is methodological, |
1:34.0 | but some of this is actually ideological, |
1:36.6 | like there is an ideological component |
1:38.6 | of nationalism, post second international that we kind of have to deal with because it's kind of similar to the idea about capital that there's a paradox in the dialectical movement according to the way Marxists understood this from the second international forward in that developing capital under certain egeses is actually good because it develops productive capacity, |
2:10.3 | but there's a counter tendency according to classical Marxists of the tendency of the right of profit to fall that get bound up in each other and one of the things that I've talked to people about that ties into this actually directly is Bucharen's theory of imperialism and Lenin's subsequent development and encapsulation. I mean he did and |
2:33.2 | encapsulation I mean he did there's differences between |
2:36.2 | Leonard Bukkarn but theory of imperialism is actually tied up and trying to answer the |
2:42.2 | question of these two opposing tendencies, which is the tendency of capital development and capital monopolization, which creates the preconditions for a lot of socialism, according to Ingalls and |
2:53.4 | socialism utopian and scientific. |
2:56.8 | But the tendency of the rate of the fall, |
3:00.0 | rate of profits fall, |
3:00.9 | either in crisis theory or a miseration theory depending on what period of Berkshire reading, |
3:06.6 | which is a completely different tendency. |
3:10.1 | The theory of imperialism, and one thing I'm going to say as we talk about this because the reasons why I want to do nationalisms is I want to talk about imperialism and there's a bunch of elephants in the room when we talk about this. |
3:22.0 | But I tend to agree with Stephen Hamel of the measures. the room when we talk about this. Yeah. |
... |
Please login to see the full transcript.
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Sean KB and AP Andy, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.
Generated transcripts are the property of Sean KB and AP Andy and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.
Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.