meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The Strange and Unusual Podcast

Conjuring Magic and Murder: A Mystery in Motor City

The Strange and Unusual Podcast

Alyson Horrocks | Morbid Network

True Crime, Society & Culture, Exhibit C, History

4.71.8K Ratings

🗓️ 22 September 2018

⏱️ 64 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

On July 3, 1929, Italian immigrant and occult mystic healer, Benny Evangelist, was beheaded with an ax in his home office. The killer than murdered Benny's sleeping wife, Santina, and their four children upstairs. The murders remain a mystery, but what kind of motivation could inspire such a frenzied and brutal attack? In this episode, we delve into occult practices, magic, folk Catholicism, magical healers, a suicide inspired by fear of the ax killer, Italian folklore, as well as a look at the misconceptions about immigrants at the time, and how that may have affected the case, leaving it a perplexing, eternal mystery.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

It was around 11 o'clock in the morning on July 3rd, 1929. When real estate dealer Vincent Elias stood in front of the comfortable two-story family home on Detroit's east side.

0:19.0

The home belonged to Benny and Centina Evangelist, and in the booming economy of 1920s Detroit, Michigan,

0:27.0

Benny and Italian immigrant had done quite well for himself.

0:31.5

So well, in fact, that he'd just arranged for the purchase an additional home a farm in the country

0:38.6

And Vincent Elias was there to deliver the paperwork

0:45.2

Vincent knocked firmly but gently on the front door.

0:55.6

His eyes downcast. He shifted his weight as he waited. The late morning sun was already hot enough to make him sweat. It's rays burning a damning heat against his back. Odd, he thought. The house is so quiet. This was a home filled with small children, always brimming with

1:06.7

bustling life, and yet at such an hour it was strangely quiet. Vincent waited, listening for the sound of approaching footsteps,

1:16.0

but deathly quiet was all that met his ears.

1:20.0

He knocked again.

1:21.0

He gave it a couple more minutes before finally opening the door.

1:27.0

An appointment had been arranged with Benny after all,

1:30.0

so his appearance in the home wouldn't be a surprise.

1:35.0

He called out from the entrance to announce his presence,

1:38.0

but there was still no response.

1:41.0

Feeling an inexplicable dread, he cautiously made his way to a small room that served as Benny's office.

1:51.0

Unable to shake the apprehension that was building, he slowly opened the door.

1:57.0

And there he found him.

2:00.0

Dressed in a well-made suit, with his arms folded tight, Benny was sitting at his desk.

2:07.0

The true nature of the sight before him took a moment to register,

2:11.0

but once it did, horror filled his body and grasped his throat, paralyzing

2:16.6

his ability to speak.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Alyson Horrocks | Morbid Network, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Alyson Horrocks | Morbid Network and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.