I need to begin this episode with something that's stayed with me for a really long time.

When this case first broke, I was relieved that Arvin Shreve confessed, that he told his followers to come in,

and that in all 12 predators ended up convicted.

At the time, it felt like a real victory,

and in some ways it was.

Many of the children had already been treated harshly

by defense attorneys during those preliminary hearings.

So the guilty pleas spared the children

from being forced back onto those witness stands to relive some of the memories that would haunt them throughout their lives.

What happened mattered then, and it still matters now.

But over the years, I've not been able to shake the feeling that Arvin Shreve may have been playing a longer game, even if it ultimately backfired on him.

After Arvin spoke to us that night, Jackie and I had a sleepless night, and we decided that

we were going to move. So we talked about how we were going to do that, and I remember that

Arvin had said that he had wanted to develop or purchase that entire block,

where he could have women come and stay and start to develop his society, I guess,

his Zion society and his sexual way of life.

We wanted no part of it, but we knew that our house was one of his prime homes that he had discussed.

So I went over to Arvin's house, I think the next day or the next, and spoke with him,

expressed to him that what he had told us was not all right with us

and was not of my beliefs and teachings, to which he tried to tell us that it was celestial law

and not this carnal law that we live here on earth. Anyways, I told him that we were moving and that he had an opportunity to buy our house if he wanted to.

A couple days later, he got back with me, said that he was going to purchase the home for the price that I'd asked.

...