Our card this week is Charles Chuck McGraw, the ten of spades from Indiana.

Charles' bold suits and charismatic personality made him a standout.

He was also a man who liked money, earning it, flashing it, and spending it.

And trying to untangle Charles' different threads of income

and what may or may not be connected to his death

has kept investigators busy for decades,

especially when some of that income was almost definitely under the table.

I'm Ashley Flowers, and this under the table.

I'm Ashley Flowers, and this is the deck. Thank you. Back in 1988, 5 o'clock was the end of the nurses' shift at St. Francis Hospital in Beach Grove, Indiana.

So by 520 on October 7th, Carla Feliciano and her co-worker were walking to their cars. But something struck her as off.

Right next to her car, parked on the second floor of the garage, there was a burgundy and gray Cadillac,

Seville with the engine idling. Carla peered through the rolled-up window, and inside she saw a man in a brown tweed jacket like slumped over the center console.

His left arm rested between his legs and there was what looked like blood on his hand.

So right away, her nursing instincts kicked in.

She shouted at her colleague to go get help while she opened the unlocked door and checked

for signs of life. But there was nothing. Within a few minutes, Carla's co-worker returned with a doctor

who confirmed what Carla already knew. The man in the Cadillac was dead. Looking into the car,

Carla could see that he'd been shot once on the left side of his head and neck area.

When police arrived shortly after, they recognized the victim immediately.

He was 53-year-old Charles McGraw, the hospital's food services director.

Charles McGraw was super popular at the hospital.

Some of the officers that responded that they even knew Charles McGraw.

...