meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Accused

Chapter 3: The case unfolds

Accused

Cincinnati Enquirer

True Crime, Documentary, Exhibit C, Society & Culture

4.47.7K Ratings

🗓️ 17 October 2017

⏱️ 36 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

With physical evidence and eyewitnesses on their side, police begin compiling a case against William Virgil — but does it hold up under scrutiny?

Subscribe to Accused so you never miss an episode: https://www.smarturl.it/accusedpodcast

Subscribe to Accused so you never miss an episode: https://www.smarturl.it/accusedpodcast

Thank you to our sponsors:

Zip Recruiter - Learn how to hire smarter and get a free trial when you visit them here:

www.ziprecruiter.com/accused

Brooklinen - Get $20 an free shipping when you use promo code ACCUSED here:

www.brooklinen.com

Bombas - Get 20% off your first order when you visit them here:

www.bombas.com/accused

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

I'm not a good place.

0:10.0

Previously, unequivoced.

0:12.0

I opened the door and when I looked inside, I knew something was wrong because there was things on all other places.

0:21.0

It's a good place.

0:26.0

I mean, it's stuff that I did then that I know I paid for in that 20 years because karma is a beast.

0:33.0

You know what I'm saying?

0:34.0

And regardless of the fact that I was innocent of this, I still was paying for things that I had done.

0:49.0

I'm Amber Hunt and this is accused, the unsolved murder of Ritha Welch.

0:56.0

Just before William Virgil was to go on trial for the murder of Ritha Welch, his defense lawyer made a shocking discovery that seemed to throw the prosecution's case in jeopardy.

1:08.0

Robert Patton got a call alerting him to additional files related to the case that he hadn't been given yet.

1:15.0

He didn't think much of it at first, he said, because he already had a huge stack of documents.

1:20.0

But then he noticed that the letters GJ had been scrolled on all the files already given to him, but not on the new ones that were just surfacing.

1:29.0

He started to wonder what the letters meant.

1:32.0

And when I went over there, there was a box, you know, like a liquor box. It must have 15 files in it, maybe more.

1:40.0

So you could look at them and they were dead ends and I agree, but many of them were suspects, including this becker fellow, who boyfriend, and the other one was Isaac Grubbs, who I had represented at least twice before.

1:55.0

Once I had taken a truck for a part of my fee. So I knew who the guy was, I knew he was violent because he was always in trouble with the law.

2:04.0

In short, three days before jury selection, Patton was given a box filled with information about possible alternate suspects. Suddenly he realized what GJ meant.

2:15.0

It's what they had given to the grand jury. The rest was, well, not.

2:21.0

So what they did is everyone that was related that helped them tie the case back to Virgil, they put that piece of paper in a separate file that was basically the Virgil file.

2:32.0

It was marked GJ at the top after they went through it and decided what they were going to give the grand jury, or what they were going to testify to at the grand jury.

2:41.0

That grand jury apparently indicted William Virgil on murder charges without ever hearing that anyone else could have done it.

2:51.0

That last minute discovery by Robert Patton delayed the trial from months. It had originally been scheduled for April 18, 1988, a year and a week after Ritha's death.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Cincinnati Enquirer, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Cincinnati Enquirer and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.