I'm normally I find out what happened where it happened how it happened who did it I've

never been a big person on why because that just gets really really bizarre.

I've got Weinberger, investigative journalist and former deputy sheriff.

I'm Anna Sige Nikolasi, former New York City homicide prosecutor and host of investigation

discoveries to conviction.

And this is Anatomy of Murder.

Today we're going to a small Midwest town called Inverness, Illinois, but you may as well

call it paradise.

They actually worked when they created this town to recreate a new England-like type setting.

They wanted to preserve the natural landscape.

They actually have the roads going around the hills rather than through them.

The only business in this town is a golf course and they have a no fence policy trying

to make sure that neighbors were just that good neighbors to one another.

The town's about 8,000 people, very affluent.

All the houses are on one acre lots.

There's no bars.

As we refer to it as you know, Mayberry with money.

This is Detective Mike Kirby who was one of only 12 police officers who covered that jurisdiction.

We were everything.

The motto as you catch it you clean it.

You did patrol work.

If you caught a case you worked the case.

...