meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Godsplaining

Can a Good Person Tell a Lie?

Godsplaining

Dominican Friars Province of St. Joseph

Religion & Spirituality

4.91.4K Ratings

🗓️ 18 June 2026

⏱️ 35 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Most people instinctively say that lying is wrong—until they're presented with an extreme case. What if a murderer came to your door? What if hiding the truth could protect an innocent person? In this episode of Godsplaining, Fr. Gregory and Fr. Bonaventure explore traditional Christian teaching on lying, drawing from St. Augustine, St. Thomas Aquinas, and even Immanuel Kant. They discuss why truthfulness is so central to the moral life, whether every lie is sinful, and how Catholics should think about difficult situations where telling the truth seems costly. The conversation goes beyond rules and exceptions to ask a deeper question: Do you want to be the kind of person who tells the truth? For the St. Dominic Rosary and more from the Catholic Woodworker: https://catholicwoodworker.com/products/st-dominic-rosary?utm_source=godsplaining&utm_medium=shownotes&utm_campaign=stdominic Join Exodus 90 and their Return of the King challenge: https://exodus90.com/godsplaining   Limited spots! Sign up for the 2026 Men's Retreat in August: https://godsplaining.org/events-2/mens-retreat-brevard-nc-august-2026/   Send your questions for the friars to: godsplaining@opeast.org Subscribe to our channel https://www.youtube.com/c/Godsplaining   Support the Podcast Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/godsplaining Shop our merch: https://godsplaining.org/store/   Shop Books Written by the Friars Justice: Judge Rightly, Give Freely: https://a.co/d/0dx0V5AT O Sacred Banquet: Exploring the Eucharistic Mystery with Saint Thomas Aquinas: https://a.co/d/0hLdv7oU Witness: https://www.avemariapress.com/products/witness-1 Training the Tongue: https://stpaulcenter.com/store/training-the-tongue-and-growing-beyond-sins-of-speech Your Eucharistic Identity: https://ignatius.com/your-eucharistic-identity-yeip/ St. Dominic's Way of Life: https://www.amazon.com/Saint-Dominics-Way-Life-Knowing/dp/1681929392 Prudence: Choose Confidently, Live Boldly: https://www.amazon.com/Prudence-Choose-Confidently-Live-Boldly/dp/1681927322/   Connect on Social Media Follow us on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/godsplaining/ Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/godsplaining/ Follow us on X: https://x.com/godsplaining   To learn more about the Province of St. Joseph visit: www.opeast.org To support the Province of St. Joseph visit: www.dominicanfriars.org

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

This is Father Gregory Pine.

0:04.9

And this is Father Bonameter Chapman.

0:06.4

And welcome to Godsplining.

0:07.5

Thanks to all those who support us.

0:09.1

If you enjoy the show, please consider making a monthly donation on Patreon.

0:12.5

Be sure to like and subscribe to the podcast wherever you listen to the podcast.

0:17.1

Man, I got it wrong that time.

0:18.9

Eh.

0:19.6

That's okay.

0:20.2

Who's to say?

0:37.7

Who is to say? I suppose those who have done an inductive study of the way in which I open all of the episodes of God Splending from about three years ago up until the present date will know on the basis of said inductive study that there are patterns emerging and those patterns would seem to suggest a script. Yes.

0:54.9

And that I have diverted from the script in at least one word. Yes, but they don't know if there is a script. They don't know if there's a, there is a script or if there's like a natural law precept which pertains to the following of scripts as concerns the introducing of podcasts. It's definitely not a natural law precept of that. You sure? Yeah, positive law probably. or like self-given law.

1:44.5

Yeah, but insofar as the positive law is rooted in the natural law, I mean, like, this could be somewhere in the tertiary quaternary type. Probably eternal law. Okay, yeah, exactly. We're pretty sure about that. Well, God follows scripts insofar as he himself is the script and he follows his nature. He is the director. That's it. He is the director. And the producer? And? And the actor? Yes. And the audience. Wait. Nice. At least he is. And the popcorn dealer. Can one speak of before creation? Things are getting out of control. But it's better that they get out of control because we're things to always be in control that would take a lot of the spice-slash-variety out of life. Do you think Kant would say that, or would he disagree? Is he there for spice and variety? He's not there for spice and variety that much. Yeah, he's a pretty regular kind of guy. He's there for regularity? He's there for regular.

1:45.5

The taking of naps in Konexburg?

1:46.3

The taking of naps with Joseph Green in Kornigsberg.

1:48.2

Yeah, exactly.

1:49.2

The long lunches too.

1:50.6

What do you think Kant would think about the fact that his hometown now lies within the

1:55.1

bounds of Russia?

1:56.2

Well, it was occupied by Russia at a certain point during the wars. And so he taught Russian soldiers. Really? So he knew, yeah. So he knew Russians. He taught the soldiers and such. So this would be part for the course, I suppose. Yeah. I feel like St. Thomas Aquinas would be more comfortable with the fluidity of things on account of the fact that he observes that nature obtains always, or for the most part. Yeah, it's probably right. He was also Southern Italian. So it's kind of like...

2:20.2

Goes with the flow. That's probably right. Kingdom of the two Sicily's type, Geneseecois. That's French book. Yeah, he's probably not as anxious about getting stuff ordered, you know, even though the wise man is the one who orders things correctly. Yeah. It's like, those God's ordering things, we're good to go.

2:34.1

That's true for Kant, too, but Khan wants to do a little more.

...

Transcript will be available on the free plan in 25 days. Upgrade to see the full transcript now.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Dominican Friars Province of St. Joseph, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Dominican Friars Province of St. Joseph and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.