meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Now Playing - The Movie Review Podcast

Book Review: Second Variety by Philip K. Dick

Now Playing - The Movie Review Podcast

Venganza Media, Inc.

Tv & Film, Film History, Tv & Film:film Reviews, Film Reviews, Film Interviews

4.53K Ratings

🗓️ 22 January 2011

⏱️ 11 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

This novella is a real scream Books & Nachos is now part of Now Playing Podcast. Before our book reviews were branded as Now Playing Podcast Book Reviews, they were released under a separate show called Books & Nachos. That podcast focused on book discussions, most of which tied directly into films we were covering on Now Playing. We’ve now merged those episodes into the main Now Playing Podcast feed for easier access and a complete archive. But these older episodes still have the original Books & Nachos intro and credits on those older recordings.  This week, Stuart continues his discussion of Philip K. Dick's works with Second Variety, Dick’s 1953 short story about autonomous killing machines that evolve beyond human control. The tale of soldiers trapped in a war against weapons that can perfectly mimic their creators would later inspire the 1995 film Screamers, but how does the original prose stack up against its cinematic offspring? Stuart digs into Dick’s bleak worldview, razor-sharp concepts, and unsettling twists to determine whether this story still cuts deep. {Philip K. Dick Series} {Book Reviews}

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

This is Books and Nachos, a podcast for those of us who find excitement in the pages of a good book. Fiction and nonfiction, graphic novels, and more. We are here to help you find something great to read.

0:27.5

Hello and welcome to books and nachos.

0:31.2

This is the Vinganza Media podcast about all things in print.

0:36.4

My name is Stuart in L.A., and I'm here to talk about the short story, Second Variety.

0:39.3

It was written by Philip K. Dick in 1953 and was eventually made into a movie called Screamers in 1995. If you head over to nowplaying

0:48.1

podcast.com, you'll find myself, Jacob, Brock, reviewing all of the movies that were made from Philip K. Dick

0:56.7

works. And this week, we're talking about screamers. Here, I'm going to look at second variety

1:02.0

and see what the original story had to offer. It's very much a Cold War story. We see Earth

1:09.4

decimated in another war with the Russians. I think this is an

1:14.5

ongoing theme of both Philip K. Dick during this time period, but the whole 1950s really was caught up

1:20.6

in the clash and the nuclear anxiety. Well, here, most of Earth is now a barren wasteland, and we get the impression that a lot of people have moved off colony to the moon.

1:31.9

The Americans are hiding in a bunker, and at the start of the story, a Russian soldier is approaching and is taken out by their weapon.

1:41.9

It's not called a screamer.

1:43.4

It's actually referred to as a claw,

1:45.3

but it's the same concept. There's a mechanical sphere that burrows through the ground and takes

1:51.3

you out unless you're wearing a protective arm band known as a tab. It will kill anything alive.

1:58.5

Rats, humans, it's not discriminating.

2:01.2

It is a simple device programmed to kill anything that is alive.

2:06.2

So the Americans wearing their tabs,

2:08.9

tricking the claws into thinking that they aren't alive,

2:12.5

go to inspect the Russian soldier that was sneaking up on them

2:15.6

and find out he wasn't sneaking.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Venganza Media, Inc., and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Venganza Media, Inc. and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.