This is an IHeart podcast.

Guaranteed Human.

Topics featured in this episode may be disturbing to some listeners.

Please take care while listening.

It's a deep, dark secret.

And fortunately, oftentimes, we're able to find content and actually talk with the suspect and get an admission that, yeah, it was me.

I'm Andre Gunning. This is Betrayal Episode 5. Beyond Wildest Imagination.

We ended up staying in Utah for more than a week. I'm not complaining. It's a beautiful place to wake up and start work every day.

Another woman from the Salt Lake City area had reached out to us and we wanted to meet her.

Mandy had listened to Jennifer Facing's story in season one.

She wrote,

The same time Jennifer was going through her trauma, I was going through mine. He was my fairy tale, the love of my life, and I was blindsided to say the least.

I lost everything.

Hearing Jen's story helped me not feel so alone and gave me more strength.

I can't say enough. Thank you.

So we invited Mandy to our Airbnb to meet Ashley.

When you're in a small club that no one wants to belong to,

it's comforting to meet someone else who's been through it.

Here's Mandy speaking with Ashley.

What was it about listening to her story that like,

was it just the whole betrayal?

Like just the fact that you just knew nothing about the person that you were supposed to know everything about?

...