meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The YNAB Podcast

Ask Jesse: Is All Money Just Savings?

The YNAB Podcast

YNAB

Consolidation, Total, Budget, Dave, Peace, Money, A, Education, Ynab, Finance, Bankruptcy, Makeover, Fpu, Software, Management, Personal, Need, Ramsey, Financial, University, Debt, Kids & Family, You

4.71.1K Ratings

🗓️ 3 October 2022

⏱️ 6 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

A listener, Tom, writes into the show to express some confusion over what constitutes "savings" in a budget following the YNAB method. During a call with his bank to discuss refinancing, Tom was asked how much savings he had on hand, a question which dumbfounded him. Technically, everything in the budget is savings, he reasoned, since every dollar had been subjected to Rule One, and was sitting in categories to be spent sooner or later. So... is all money just savings in that case?

Jesse offers a saying from one of the YNAB teachers, that all savings is really just... spending! Money exists to be spent -- sometimes now, sometimes tomorrow, and sometimes years in the future. But money that is not spent eventually is useless, so in that sense all "savings" is really just money waiting to be spent.

Got a question for Jesse? Send him an email:

[email protected]

Sign up for a free 34-day trial of YNAB at www.youneedabudget.com

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hello, Wine Everest. My name is Jesse Meekum with another episode of The Wine and Podcast

0:09.0

where we teach you four rules to help you stop in paycheck to paycheck, get out of debt

0:12.4

and save more money. Today is an Ask Jesse episode. A question from Tommy said, my bank

0:18.7

phone made a day to discuss remorogging and locking in a fixed interest rate for the

0:22.0

next few years. And one of the questions they asked me in the process was, how much money

0:25.6

do you have in savings? It stumped me. I could go for the combined amounts in my specific

0:30.1

savings categories, like an emergency fund, wish farm items, etc. But then that excludes

0:34.7

my rule two funds, which definitely are savings in their own right. I could give the amount

0:38.6

in actual savings accounts, but being a wine abuser, all of my money is in a single check-in

0:43.2

account. So that would equal nothing. I eventually started on the fact that all of my money

0:47.4

could potentially be classed as savings, as it has all been subjected to rule one. And

0:52.2

if it hasn't been spent, then it's in the budget and waiting to be spent at some point.

0:56.4

So he said, he tried to explain my thought process to the lady on the phone, and she

0:59.1

was intrigued. So then he goes on to pitch wine abuser. You know? And that, there we go.

1:07.1

That's what I'm talking about. So he said, is all money within the budget classed as savings

1:11.9

or have I gone too broad? You know what, Tom? I don't think so. Our teachers have actually

1:17.6

taught that. I think Lee is one of our teachers. He's often said, I might be saying this backwards

1:24.2

now, but he basically says, yeah, all spending is savings. I think that's how he says it.

1:30.5

Or all savings is just spending later. Either way, you look at it. We're talking about

1:34.8

the same thing. It's just money with a different deadline attached to it, really. So you can

1:40.9

say, oh, I'm saving up to buy a car. Was that savings? Yeah. Okay. You're saving up for it.

1:48.3

Well, I'm saving up to buy groceries tomorrow. Okay. You know? Or I'm going to spend this money

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from YNAB, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of YNAB and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.