meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
BibleThinker

Answering Hitchens' Impossible Question

BibleThinker

Mike Winger

Christianity, Religion & Spirituality

4.82.6K Ratings

🗓️ 27 November 2020

⏱️ 3 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

This is a clip from one of the most important videos I've made, here's the full video - https://youtu.be/VIgVAlI8T2c Christopher Hitchens is an icon to many atheists. He was an entertaining mix of brilliant, snarky, irreverent and British. One thing he is well-known for is debating theists and making fools of them, at least from the perspective of some people. I was always struck by this particular challenge that he threw out regularly in debates. Hitchens was so proud of it that I once heard him encouraging crowds of atheists to use this challenge as well. He felt that it really proved something, and I dare say many atheists agreed. What's really odd to me is that none of his debate partners (to my knowledge) ever offered a good response to his challenge. This is odd because the primary moral of loving God with all our heart, mind, soul and strength answers this atheist dilemma quite well. It not only answers the question it gets right to the heart of what an atheist has lost when they have sadly embraced a false worldview which rejects God's existence. To any atheists that have read this far I'd like to say that this isn't meant to be a smackdown or a slap in the face. Rather, this is meant to open a door to the possibility that the most important thing in life is being robbed from you, and your atheism is the robber. After I uploaded this video a friend sent me a clip of William Lane Craig answering this challenge 10 years ago! I was surprised to see how similar his answer was and now I’m wondering how much my own answer may have been influenced by Craig’s but without me remembering it. Obviously we are both influenced by the teaching of Jesus, but still, It seems likely that I heard this somewhere along the way and forgot. Anyhow, here is Craig’s answer (he is always brilliant). https://youtu.be/qqt3Ie8l-fo

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

I also have a wager that I put to the religious in these cases and you may be interested to know that I've tried it with everyone from the guy who founded Bush's faith-based initiative, Mr. Olaski, to various Baptist pastors, a Buddhist non, a rabbi,

0:14.8

charismatic Catholic, various pastors on radio and television

0:18.4

all up and down the country, not yet an answer from them.

0:21.7

It's simple. You have to name or cite a moral action performed or

0:29.6

a moral statement made by a believer that could not have been made by an atheist. That's all you

0:35.8

have to do and it cannot be done.

0:40.3

Christopher Hitchins, who was one of the most famous atheists of our last generation, he would do debates, and one of the things he would like to spring on people and debates, on Christians he's debating, is the question, what moral thing can a Christian do that an atheist can't do?

0:56.8

And he would do this all the time. I mean, it was like a mantra of his in his debates.

1:00.5

Tell me one moral thing that a Christian can do that an atheist can't do.

1:04.3

And so often his debate partners would just go, I don't know.

1:07.7

That's a good question.

1:08.7

I don't know. And they wouldn't have anything.

1:09.7

And that, here's something I think is common in modern day atheism pop atheism online is that if they

1:16.7

ask a question you don't know how to answer, then they think they've won.

1:22.4

You just saying I don't know, it means they're won. Like you just saying I don't know it means they're right which is not how

1:26.4

reality works right because otherwise every three-year-old is right as soon as they

1:30.4

learn how to say why why why but that's not how reality works but at any

1:35.3

rate one pastor finally answered Christopher Hitchins and he says well what

1:38.9

moral thing can a Christian do that an atheist can't do tit Tyth! I thought that's probably not the best answer.

1:47.0

Technically sort of, yeah, I mean, atheists aren't going to tide.

1:50.0

But as I thought about it, I sat down and I did what sometimes I do.

1:53.2

I just hit pause on the debate and I sat and I went, hmm, how would I answer that?

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Mike Winger, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Mike Winger and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.