meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
I Wish You Were Here

A Fatal Divorce: The Double Homicide of Monique and Spencer Tepe

I Wish You Were Here

Michelle Cuervo

True Crime

4.91.2K Ratings

🗓️ 23 February 2026

⏱️ 38 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

In this episode: On December 30, 2025, dentist Spencer Tepe didn't show up for work. When police arrived at his Columbus home for a welfare check, they found him and his wife Monique shot to death. Their two young children, ages 1 and 4, were unharmed inside the house. Within weeks, investigators arrested Monique's ex-husband, vascular surgeon Michael McKee. Surveillance footage showed him stalking the couple's home weeks before the murders. Friends say he'd been threatening Monique for years, telling her he could "kill her at any time" and that "she will always be his wife." This is the story of a divorce that turned deadly—and the red flags surrounding the case.  #TrueCrime #TrueCrimePodcast #Podcast #CrimeStory #DoubleHomicide #SpencerTepe #MoniqueTepe #MichaelMcKee #TrueStory #IWishYouWereHerePod #UnsolvedMystery #TrueCrimeStoryteller 🎧 Listen to the Podcast Apple Podcasts: I Wish You Were Here on Apple Podcast Spotify:I Wish You Were Here on Spotify All Platforms: https://hoo.be/mshellllly 🤝 This Episode Is Sponsored By COZY EARTH Start the New Year off right and give your home the luxury it deserves, and make home the best part of life.  🔗 Link: cozyearth.con/WISH for up to 20% off! 🤝 This Episode Is Sponsored By REMI Start the new year right and use code WISH to get  50% off your purchase of a new night guard! 🔗 Link: shopremi.com/WISH  🌐 Follow Me TikTok: TikTok Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mshellllly/ YouTube: I Wish You Were Here on YouTube 🖤 Disclaimer This episode discusses real events involving real people. Information is presented based on publicly available sources at the time of recording. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

The morning of December 30th, 2025, began like any other, at Athens Dental Depot in Ohio.

0:06.9

Employees arrived at their office for their usual workday expecting to see Dr. Spencer Tepe,

0:12.9

the reliable dentist who was never late.

0:15.3

But Spencer, he wasn't there when he should have been, and his absence was so out of character and so unusual that it

0:23.0

resulted in a 911 call asking for a wellness check just before 9 a.m. At 8.58 a.m., Dr. Mark

0:30.6

Varroes, the owner of the business, called 911. Quote, he's been very reliable and we cannot get in

0:36.4

touch with him, his wife, his family,

0:39.0

anyone that lives in that house. We're very, very concerned because this is very out of character

0:43.6

and we cannot get in touch with his wife, which is probably the most concerning thing, end quote.

0:48.9

He also told the operator that the couple had two little kids, again, emphasizing his concern.

0:56.2

And the operator on the phone,

1:03.0

and this is just my opinion, she sounded like she did not want to be bothered saying, okay,

1:08.8

well, people, sometimes people just don't show up for work. Maybe he's sick. I don't know.

1:14.0

Which, okay, fair. Sometimes people don't show up for work, but Spencer wasn't only a dentist. He was a dentist who helped run the entire office and he always would let

1:20.9

someone know if he was either running late or if his schedule was going to look any different that day.

1:25.7

He always gave someone a heads up.

1:29.0

What he never did was just not show up without telling anyone anything.

1:34.9

And that day, on December 30th, what nobody knew yet was that just hours earlier between

1:40.8

two in the morning and five in the morning, someone had entered the Tepe home,

1:45.6

someone who knew exactly where to go, someone who had been watching, waiting, and planning.

1:52.3

And in those dark early hours of the morning, two lives were brutally taken while their children

1:58.0

slept, just rooms away.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Michelle Cuervo, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Michelle Cuervo and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.