meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
When Diplomacy Fails Podcast

#45: 31 July 1914 II - From Russia with Lies

When Diplomacy Fails Podcast

Zack Twamley

19th Century, 20th Century, International Relations, Politics, Thirty Years' War, Korean War, 18th Century, First World War, Phd, 17th Century, European History, History, War

4.8773 Ratings

🗓️ 3 February 2025

⏱️ 40 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Russian general mobilisation was underway, and with red imperial posters announcing this grave new step, it could hardly be kept a secret. Yet, somehow, Germany seemed the only power truly in the loop. The question was, why were France and Britain unaware of it? Were they unaware, thanks to their ambassadors in St Petersburg, or had London and Paris chosen to ignore this seismic step, in their rush to blame Berlin?


The behaviour of Ambassadors Buchanan and Paleologue certainly deserves some scrutiny. Both men were on location in St Petersburg, and could see exactly what German ambassador Pourtales could see, so why had their announcements taken so long to arrive? Until they got official confirmation, the British and French governments could not be expected to act, and certainly would not restrain Russia.


The Russian government had a vested interest in maintaining this confusion, and Sergei Sazonov made little effort to spread the news with an official announcement. The news was spreading, but slowly, and Sazonov counted on the Central Powers reacting in such a manner that few would later remember who had moved first. Sazonov was fortunate in his adversaries, but in Berlin particularly, Russian mobilisation meant the end of peaceful diplomacy, even if the blind Entente refused to see it.


Support the July Crisis series, join the conversation, and find out more through these links:

  1. Do you want ad-free episodes with scripts attached, and bonus content? Support us on Patreon and you can suggest July Crisis episodes!
  2. Join our Facebook group as we make our way through this fascinating series!
  3. Click here to see our July Crisis workspace in Perlego, you'll find every source you need!
Get bonus content on Patreon

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

In summer 1914, the world went to war.

0:04.6

Now 110 years later, we go back to those figures, to those debates, to those questions,

0:12.2

in the greatest failure in the history of diplomacy.

0:16.3

I am Dr. Zach Twomley. You're listening to When Diplomacy Fails, will even at the last time. I trust in God that he will even at the last hour bring the Tsar to his senses and avert the frightful disaster which Russia's procedure threatens to bring upon the world.

1:06.3

Should that not be possible, however, I trust that shoulder to shoulder we may win victory in the war

1:12.5

that has been forced upon us, just as we have been unitedly striving with all our strength now

1:18.1

for over five and thirty years to maintain peace. Kaiser Wilhelm to Emperor Franz

1:24.6

Joseph in an unused draft telegram, 31st of July 1914.

1:31.0

The countdown to the First World War involved a morass of miniature struggles which each government had to fight.

1:38.5

These included the struggle for military preparations, the struggle to persuade the population that the cause was just, and the

1:45.4

simultaneous struggle to persuade Europe of the same thing. One struggle which is easy to overlook

1:51.0

in our era of instantaneous communications is the struggle for up-to-date information. By the 31st of July,

1:58.4

one could argue that Germany had surged ahead in this struggle

2:02.0

and was the most informed of all contemporary governments.

2:06.6

Unfortunately, as Berlin discovered,

2:09.0

not all who participated in this struggle for information were playing by the same rules.

2:14.5

We left the last episode on something of a cliffhanger,

2:16.9

while Ambassador Portelae

2:18.6

managed to report Russian General Mobilization back to Berlin before noon. His counterparts,

2:25.0

Buchanan, representing Britain, and Palliologue representing France, took much longer. These delays

2:31.6

affected the information available to Paris and London, but they also

2:35.4

influenced how those governments interpreted the crisis and, critically, how they interpreted

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Zack Twamley, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Zack Twamley and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.