Is hell unfair?

Carla Bursard, next.

Hello and welcome to Focus, the Catholic Answers Podcast for living, understanding, and defending your Catholic faith.

I'm Sy Kelly at your host.

And today, we actually tackle what, in many ways, is probably the most difficult doctrine of Christian faith,

the doctrine of hell, of the existence of hell, and of the fact that some go there.

It's difficult for emotional reasons.

It's difficult for intellectual reasons as well.

Like, there are good, intellectual, strong, intellectual objections to hell.

And even Thomas Aquinas struggled with this.

I would say, well, maybe some of the Thomas will say, no, he didn't struggle.

But left a lot of questions unanswered.

Let's say that.

We're not going to try to answer all the questions about hell here.

We're going to try to take seriously one question about hell that was sent to us by a listener.

That question has to do whether an infinite punishment for a finite sin is fair.

Here's Carla Bursard.

Carla, thanks for being with us again.

Hey Sy, thanks for having me, brother.

This is a good one because we've been asking people, you know, send us questions if there's something you want to cover.

And a man named Joshua did send us a question.

And so we thought, and it seemed like a perfect question for you.

...