meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
The Road to Now

#298 The Election of 1912 w/ Michael Patrick Cullinane (Third Party Series #3)

The Road to Now

Benjamin Sawyer

Society & Culture, History

4.8628 Ratings

🗓️ 4 March 2024

⏱️ 53 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

The Presidential election of 1912 was an unusual moment in American history. It featured an embattled incumbent President facing criticism from his former allies. It offered voters a choice between the sitting President and his predecessor. And when it was all done, the two men who had previously won the Presidency found themselves bested by a college professor with just a few years of experience in politics.

 

So why did the predecessor, Teddy Roosevelt, become so critical of the incumbent, William Howard Taft, that he decided to break away from the Republican party to run against him? Why did the Democrats pick relative newcomer Woodrow Wilson to be their Presidential Candidate ? And is 1912 an example of how a third-party candidate can spoil an election? Let's find out.

 

Welcome to The Road To Now's Third Party Elections Series. Today: Part 3- The Election of 1912 with Michael Cullinane.

 

Dr. Michael Patrick Cullinane is Lowman Walton Chair of Theodore Roosevelt Studies at Dickinson State University and the author of multiple books, including Theodore Roosevelt's Ghost: The History and Memory of an American Icon (LSU Press, 2017). You can also hear him on his bi-weekly podcast The Gilded Age and Progressive Era, available anywhere you get The Road to Now.

 

If you enjoyed this episode, make sure to check out our previous episodes in this series:

-#1 The Election of 1824 w/ Lindsay Chervinsky

-#2 The Election of 1860 w/ Michael Green

 

This episode was edited by Gary Fletcher.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

The presidential election of 1912 was an unusual moment in American history.

0:06.6

It featured an embattled incumbent president facing criticism from his former allies.

0:11.5

It offered voters a choice between the sitting president and his predecessor.

0:16.0

And when it was all done, the two men who had previously won the presidency

0:19.3

found themselves bested by a college professor

0:22.0

with just a few years of political experience. Why did the predecessor, Teddy Roosevelt,

0:27.7

become so critical of his hand-picked successor William Howard Taft that he decided to break

0:32.7

away from the Republican Party to run against him? Why did the Democrats pick relative newcomer Woodrow Wilson

0:38.6

to be their presidential candidate? And is 1912 an example of how a third-party candidate can

0:44.1

spoil an entire election? Let's find out. Welcome to the Road to Now's third-party election

0:51.4

series. Today, part three, the election of 1912 with Michael Culliname.

0:59.8

I'm Bob Crawford. I'm Ben Sawyer. And this is the Road to Now. It is. And now, Bob, is the year

1:06.4

24, which is a election year for the presidency. And as you all know, we've been doing a series on

1:17.1

also-Rands, third-party candidates. Since there's been some discussion of that in this year's

1:22.3

election, third-party candidates, fourth-party candidates, fifth fifth party candidates, no party candidates.

1:28.7

And so there's been a lot of talk as the media tends to do of apocalyptic scenarios in

1:34.0

which one person running will throw the entire election to the person that I don't want to win

1:37.8

no matter what. And so today we're as a part of this series, we're going back and we are asking

1:43.4

is that true? Has there been a case

1:46.4

in the past where a third party candidate has really shaken things up? And I try to get to the

1:51.1

bottom of it. And even if it has or hasn't, the central question here is how do third, fourth party

1:56.3

candidates, how do they impact the election itself? How do they impact this outcome? And then hopefully try to understand better how those election years have shaped the country moving forward.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Benjamin Sawyer, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Benjamin Sawyer and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.