Here on Stolen Lives, we discuss brutal and heartbreaking crimes against children.

Themes may include child murder, torture, and sexual domestic and child abuse.

I do try to my best to remain respectful for the babies in these stories

and leave out unnecessary details that honestly, none of us need to know to understand

the frustration of why and how this ever happened.

However, if you find any of these themes triggering this podcast may not be for you.

Listen, our discretion is advised.

May 2012, Centralia, Washington.

Two-year-old Coraline Fista was left in the care of her mother's boyfriend.

He would claim the toddler drowned in the bath.

But what doctors discovered, Toddafar darker story,

one that would shock an entire community and expose a monster hiding in plain sight.

This is Coralyn's story.

Coraline Marie Fister was born March 9, 2010, in Centrilla, Washington, to parents Becky

Hugh Pell and to David Fister. Becky bringing a two-year-old girl into the relationship,

a big sister for Coraline and the two loved each other deeply.

Extremely close right from the start.

Becky and David met online two years earlier

and they immediately fell for each other.

David making them move from Iowa to Centrelia, Washington, to move in with

Becky and her then-infant daughter. David very quickly, taking on the role of father to Becky's

eldest daughter. David was working at the local subway, while Becky was a stay-home mum to the two

...