meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Best of the Left - Leftist Perspectives on Progressive Politics, News, Culture, Economics and Democracy

#1795 You Say You Want A Revolution: Successful Revolutions are the Boring Ones

Best of the Left - Leftist Perspectives on Progressive Politics, News, Culture, Economics and Democracy

Jay Tomlinson

Politics, News Commentary, News

4.53.4K Ratings

🗓️ 27 May 2026

⏱️ 235 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Air Date: 5–26-2026

Today we examine what separates successful revolutions from failed ones, ask why so many revolutions of the 2010s fell short, understand how revolutionary energy gets neutralized, and explore the strategic case for nonviolent resistance.

Full Show Notes

Transcript

Be part of the show! Leave a voice message, message us on Signal at the handle bestoftheleft.01, or email Jay@BestOfTheLeft.com

BestOfTheLeft.com/Support (Members Get Bonus Shows + No Ads!)

Use our links to shop Bookshop.org and Libro.fm for a non-evil book and audiobook purchasing experience!

Join our Discord community!


TOP TAKES

KP 1: What Makes a Revolution Successful? - The Inquiry - Air Date 5-16-18

KP 2: Left Behind: the Failed Revolutions of the 2010s - The Politics Show - Air Date 2-5-24

KP 3: Is The US In Its French Revolution Era? - Leeja Miller - Air Date 5-13-26

KP 4: How Progress Erases Itself - Dan Harumi - Air Date 5-18-26

KP 5: Why Nonviolence Wins - Degenerate Art by Andrea Pitzer - Air Date 5-14-26


(00:54:11) NOTE FROM THE EDITOR

Why the Left Keeps Losing to the Right


DEEPER DIVES

(01:13:12) SECTION A: ANATOMY OF FAILURE

A1: Lessons From a Decade of Failed Revolutions - Front Burner - Air Date 1-2-24

A2: Why Revolutions Fail - Hello Future Me - Air Date 9-9-23

A3: How and Why Revolutions Occur - LegalKimchi - Air Date 12-12-22

A4: Difference Between a Coup and a Revolution? - Sean Munger - Air Date 1-12-21


(01:54:11) SECTION B: REVISITING THE RECORD

B1: What Was the Iranian Revolution Really About? With Scott Anderson - Intelligence Squared - Air Date 11-2-25

B2: "Counter-Revolution of 1776": Was U.S. Independence War a Conservative Revolt in Favor of Slavery? - Democracy Now! - Air Date 6-27-14

B3: In Defense of Che Guevara (How the Media Lies to You) - Overzealots - Air Date 1-26-25

B4: The Warriors of a Failed Revolution - Narratively Out Loud - Air Date 9-30-20


(02:32:02) SECTION C: THE CURRENT MOMENT

C1: Why Fascism Fails - Then & Now - Air Date 5-18-26

C2: What Is the Relevance of the Russian Revolution Today? A Debate with Kshama Sawant & Eric Blanc - Haymarket Books Live - Air Date 9-26-22

C3: To Save The World, Stop Working - Extra Andrewism - Air Date 5-19-26

C4: Why the Epstein Files Didn't Start a Revolution - Uncivilized - Air Date 4-21-26

C5: "Forget What The Ruling Class Deems Unacceptable. Revolution Is Illegal" - Ed Mead On A Life In Struggle - Millennials Are Killing Capitalism - Air Date 5-26-22


(03:25:38) SECTION D: STRATEGY AND PRACTICE

D1: How To Start A Revolution Part 1 - Andrewism - Air Date 12-7-22

D2: Revolution: A How-To Guide - Hakim - Air Date 5-29-21

D3: How To Start A Revolution Part 2 - Andrewism - Air Date 12-7-22


 

Produced by Jay! Tomlinson

Visit us at BestOfTheLeft.com

Listen Anywhere! BestOfTheLeft.com/Listen Listen Anywhere!

Follow BotL: Bluesky | Mastodon | Threads | X

Like at Facebook.com/BestOfTheLeft

Contact me directly at Jay@BestOfTheLeft.com

 

 

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Welcome to this episode of the award-winning Best of the Left podcast. Today we examine what separates successful revolutions from failed ones. Ask why so many revolutions from the 2010s fell short, understand how revolutionary energy gets neutralized, and explore the strategic case for nonviolent resistance.

0:22.3

For those looking for a quick overview, the sources providing our top takes in about 50

0:26.4

minutes today include The Inquiry, The Politics Show, Leija Miller, Dan Harumi, and Degenerate

0:32.8

Art.

0:33.6

Then in the additional deeper dives half of the show, there will be more in four sections.

0:37.9

Section A, anatomy of failure, section B, revisiting the record, section C, the current moment, and section B, strategy and practice.

0:48.2

And now, on to the show.

0:59.8

Milosevic took control of Serbia security services in state media and started brutal wars with its neighbours.

1:03.5

Serge's brother fled the country to avoid the military draft,

1:06.5

and his parents, once prominent journalists, now made a living by selling smuggled petrol.

1:13.1

Within this environment, we had only took choices. We could either fight or flee.

1:17.0

And Serger chose to fight. But not through violent street protests. He and his student friends had

1:23.0

tried that in the 90s. They still had the scars. The new plan was more civilized to bring down Milosevic

1:29.6

at the next election. They created a movement called Othpoor or Resistance. Their aim

1:35.1

to get the whole country behind them. Not only political players, but people across urban

1:40.9

rural lines, people across the educational lines, and bring all of these grievances to the mass of people that participated in the elections in 2000.

1:49.0

They spread through the country, and soon tens of thousands of people had joined the movement.

1:54.8

The training was intense.

1:56.6

They learnt how to hide from the police and survive violent interrogations without fighting back.

2:02.5

When Milosevic called elections in 2000, they knew this was their big moment.

2:07.9

All they had to do now was decide which opposition candidate to back.

2:12.1

There were quite a few.

...

Transcript will be available on the free plan in 16 days. Upgrade to see the full transcript now.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Jay Tomlinson, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Jay Tomlinson and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.