meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Shaken and Disturbed

#157 - Who Murdered Marilyn Sheppard?

Shaken and Disturbed

John Thrasher and Daryn Carp

News, Improv, News Commentary, Comedy, True Crime

4.6549 Ratings

🗓️ 14 April 2024

⏱️ 36 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

In this episode, we delve deeper into the infamous 1954 murder of Marilyn Sheppard, an event that unraveled in Bay Village, Ohio, and ignited a nationwide media storm. We examine the initial night of the crime, the intense scrutiny faced by her husband, Sam Sheppard, and the dramatic legal battles that followed, including a conviction, a subsequent overturning on appeal, and a retrial. Through expert interviews and detailed analyses, we explore how this case not only captivated public attention but also shaped legal precedents regarding media influence on trials and the presumption of innocence in the American legal system.

SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE!

Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our live recordings, comment on the case, participate in polls and get shout outs! Join for as little as $5 a month right here!

Want Shaken and Disturbed merch? T-shirts, pillows, hoodies, phone cases, stickers and more are now available here: Shaken and Disturbed MERCH STORE

Follow John on Twitter @jthrasher, Instagram @jthrasher and TikTok @johnthrasher
Follow Daryn on Twitter @CarpeDaryn and Instagram @CarpeDaryn

Join the official Shake and Disturbed Fans Facebook Group here! 

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Welcome to shaken and disturbed everybody.

0:17.7

He's got a glass of water.

0:19.7

And being professional and wetting the whistle

0:22.6

before we start. I thought you were going to keep going. But here we go. The wiss. He's wetting

0:26.5

the wiss. Welcome to Shakeda disturbed. I am Derek Karp here with John Thrasher. John has water.

0:32.7

I have a sparkly substance from Trader Joe is my seltter from Trader Joe. A sparkly substance?

0:56.3

There you go. You know, I typically would have, you remember the days Darren's making a great face. By the way, watch us on YouTube so you can see all of this. Yes, subscribe. Smash that subscribe button. Look at me smashing. There you go. Oh, look at Darren's Matt. Oh, okay. That's going to be the thumbnail, isn't it, this week? It might be. It'll probably end up being that um you know last summer especially i was really going ham on diet coax every time we would record yes i don't

1:02.3

if i told you but i've started to kind of give up diet coke a little bit just a little bit i'm not

1:08.6

having one a day one or two a day like I was before.

1:11.9

I'm not buying it at the supermarket.

1:13.5

Let's put it that way.

1:27.0

If I get it, it's usually like, you know, at lunch when I'm at work or something, I might grab one. I get it out at dinner. If I'm out somewhere, I'll get a diet cook as like a treat. But yeah, I stopped buying it too just to like half less diet soda.

1:30.1

I mostly just drink salt and water now or like Gatorade Zero.

1:45.2

That's where. Because, you know, if you listen to this week's NMR that's up and available now, we talk a little bit about how I got another cold. Okay, a couple weeks ago, we had to take a week off. Yes, you did. It's like you have a child at home. I know. know well I think it's because I'm back in the office you know I had been remote for the last three years I have a

1:49.9

new position now and on a college campus is like college campus it just feels like that that's even

1:55.7

more of a petri dish of whatever the fuck college gets up going around these days. God only knows. But anyway, I'm back to

2:04.1

just water for now, which I think is probably the best and healthiest option. Of course.

2:08.9

You and Magic are on the same type of drinking diet. I wish he was. He's clearly drinking

2:14.8

and eating other things because he's three times the size he is.

2:18.6

You got to have him on the video, though. Like, remember we said that this was going to be the new

2:23.6

thing that he was going to make an appearance of some sort? It'd be nice. You know, he's been doing

2:28.0

this thing recently where he hides under my bed a lot, not like necessarily hides, but just hangs out

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from John Thrasher and Daryn Carp, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of John Thrasher and Daryn Carp and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.