December 2021.

9-1 received a phone call from a panicked father.

Actually, no rewind of that.

911 would receive multiple phone calls from a panicked father.

His phone kept cutting out and he would have to call back to report his 20-month-old daughter missing. This would be a point of contention

in the decade that followed. A baby with a broken arm goes missing overnight from her cot.

There are no signs of a break-in and no sign of what happened to the baby.

What will follow will be one of the most frustrating and rapid hold-filled cases you have ever heard.

All we know is Ayla are still missing, and there are no answers where this baby could be.

This is Ayla's story.

A happy Ayla Reynolds dancing around her living room. She was just 20 months old when she disappeared from her father's Waterville home a week before Christmas, 2011.

It's been nearly six months since Justin DePetro told police his daughter was abducted.

Her father, Justin DePetro, reported her missing on December 17th, telling

police he put her to bed the night before and she must have been abducted. In the days,

weeks and months that followed intensive searches in and around 29 Violet Avenue, a five-mile

radius around the home. Trista Reynolds and Justin DePetrio had known each other for quite a long time, but they were never really in a relationship.

They were in the same circle of friends, they knew each other kind of thing.

Ayla was an unplanned pregnancy given they were only casually seeing each other and still quite young.

They were in their early 20s.

When Trista told Justin she was pregnant with his baby, Justin actually didn't believe he was

the father, telling Trista if she was going to go through with this, that was on her, and he wanted

nothing to do with her or the baby. Aela Bell Reynolds was born Aprilth, 2010, and Trista would comment right away that she

...