meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Ancient Greece Declassified

05 Democracy and Demagogues in Ancient Athens w/ Josiah Ober

Ancient Greece Declassified

Dr. Lantern Jack

History, Education

4.8587 Ratings

🗓️ 9 January 2017

⏱️ 49 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Historian Josiah Ober of Stanford University joins us for a discussion on classical Athens and how the Athenian system compared to our own democracy. As Ober writes in his recent book The Rise and Fall of Classical Greece,

"Democracy and growth define the normal...conditions of modernity: Autocracy, while still prevalent, is regarded as aberrant, so that most autocrats pretend to be democrats.... These conditions were not normal, or even imaginable, for most people through most of human history. But, for several centuries in the first millennium BCE, democracy and growth were normal for citizens in ancient Greece."

Ober's book brings together archaeological data, economic theory, and historical and demographic models in order to explain the political developments of the classical Greek world. In it, he suggests that the Ancient Greek world was historically exceptional in many of the same ways that our modern world is. If that's true, what lessons, if any, can we take away from the Athenian experience?

Don't forget to check out the web page for this episode at greecepodcast.com/5 where you can join the conversation and vote in a poll we've set up about the future of democracy.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hi, thanks for tuning in to ancient Greece, Declassified.

0:12.0

Episode 5 Democracy and Demagogues in ancient Athens.

0:30.5

If you're listening to this podcast, then you probably live in a country that calls itself a democracy.

0:36.8

The idea of democracy has found so much support across the world in recent decades that some political thinkers have argued

0:39.3

that eventually the whole world will adopt Western liberal democracy.

0:44.3

Not everyone shares their confidence about this, but most political thinkers do seem to agree on a weaker claim,

0:51.3

namely that given the choice between democracy and autocracy, where

0:56.8

one person rules absolutely, most people will choose democracy. In other words, the desire for democracy

1:04.3

is now considered normal. But this way of thinking is historically abnormal.

1:15.8

For most of history, the majority of people, including the most educated of them,

1:19.0

did not see democracy as something desirable.

1:25.5

They saw it either as irrelevant to their situation, a mere historical curiosity,

1:30.2

or as downright negative, a recipe for mob rule.

1:37.4

As our guest today, Josiah Ober writes in his most recent book called The Rise and Fall of Classical Greece, quote, democracy and growth defined the normal conditions of modernity.

1:44.0

Autocracy, while still prevalent, is regarded as aberrant, so that most autocrats pretend to be

1:50.3

Democrats.

1:52.0

These conditions were not normal or even imaginable for most people through most of human

1:57.7

history, but for several centuries in the first millennium BCE, democracy

2:03.4

and growth were normal for citizens in ancient Greece. How that happened and why it matters is what

2:10.3

this book is about. End quote. Ober points out that there were also a few other brief moments in

2:17.1

history where some degree of democratic self-governance appeared,

2:21.3

for example in the Italian city-states during the Renaissance and in the Dutch republics of the 16th century.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Dr. Lantern Jack, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Dr. Lantern Jack and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.