meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Pleasing Terrors

026: Monster of the Deep

Pleasing Terrors

Mike Brown

Arts, Performing Arts, Personal Journals, Society & Culture

4.91.3K Ratings

🗓️ 19 September 2017

⏱️ 30 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

On November 20th, 1850 night watchman George Pollard Jr. makes his nightly rounds on the foggy Island of Nantucket, MA. An island once inhabited by proud tribes of Native Americans before the addition of the colonists. An island that was the whaling capital of the world for over a century.

The inhabitants and the whalers themselves were haunted with superstition and legends about the dark underworld of the sea and the evil that lied beneath the depths. The dangers were all too real, yet it wasn't a sea monster or a devil ascended from Davy Jones' Locker that posed the threat. It was an invisible threat that lurked in the hearts of men like the night watchman.

  • George Pollard Jr. Nantucket Nightwatchman
  • Davy Jones Locker and the dark underworld of the sea
  • The story of Jonah and being cursed by god
  • Pliny the Elder, sea monsters, the merman, and the Krakken
  • Sightings of mermaids, sirens, and mermen
  • WWI German U-boat surrenders to British patrol ship after sea monster attack
  • The legend of the black demon of the sea or megalodon
  • The story of Moby Dick based on a Nantucket whaling ship voyage
  • Mocha Dick the albino sperm whale and the voyage of the Ann Alexander
  • Captain George Pollard Jr. and the last voyage the whaling ship Essex
  • Owen Coffin and becoming what you fear most
  • November 20th, the anniversary of the destruction of the Essex

Resources:

Nantucket

How Nantucket Came to Be the Whaling Capital of the World

George Pollard Jr.
The True-Life Horror That Inspired Moby-Dick

Moby Dick by Herman Melville

Book of Jonah

Pliny the Elder

Megalodon

Mocha Dick

 

Enjoyed this episode? Please support the show by rating, reviewing, and subscribing on iTunes.

Please visit Pleasing Terrors, the podcast behind Old Charleston's best ghost tour, on Facebook and Twitter!

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Some stories were never supposed to be told, Stories that exist in the twilight between science and the

0:17.1

supernatural, between history and the horror. Stories that speak of terrifying things.

0:26.2

Stories that you want to hear.

0:29.0

Stories that you need to hear.

0:32.1

Stories that will sink their teeth in and never let you go.

0:38.0

My name is Mike Brown, and this is pleasing terrors.

0:50.0

Episode 26, Monster of the Deep.

0:54.0

Late on the night of November 20,

0:57.0

late on the night of November 20, 1850, Night Watchman George Pollard Jr. walked his beat on the

1:11.0

quiet streets of a small island 30 miles south of Cape Cod, Massachusetts.

1:18.2

He was an old man, long past his prime.

1:30.7

To the people of the island, he was a nobody, an invisible man, a shadow among shadows,

1:38.9

and he didn't mind. He considered it a mercy. He remembered a time when people knew who he was, when they remembered the horror that was associated with his name.

1:45.0

And he was content to walk the streets at night and be ignored.

1:51.0

The island was a strange place. It had a long history, one that stretched back much

1:58.9

further than the memories of its white inhabitants. It was a place enshrouded and a fog of folklore and superstition.

2:08.6

It was a place where the inhabitants often waited for bad news to roll in with the tide.

2:16.6

The island was settled by the British in 1659, but had been home to Native Americans for countless years before that.

2:25.0

And it was those early residents which gave this place its name.

2:31.0

While the locals called it the Grey Lady of the Sea because of how the

2:36.2

fog often enveloped it. Its true name was Nantucket, which was thought to have meant,

2:44.0

in the midst of the waters or faraway land.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Mike Brown, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Mike Brown and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.