When a Northern Kentucky couple are murdered in their own home, investigators discover the strangest crime scene of their careers.

An active but perplexing investigation unfolds as investigators attempt to determine who ended the quiet, peaceful lives of two beloved grandparents in this episode of Last Seen Alive.

Thank you. episode of Last Seen Alive. Thanks for listening to Last Seen Alive. I'm your host, Leah, crime analyst by day and true crime

storyteller by night. As always, I'm your co-host Scott. Bill and Peggy Stevenson were last seen

alive on May 27, 2011. They were both 74 years old at the time and had been married to each other for decades. In fact,

they'd been high school sweethearts. During their years together, they'd build a life together on

Kentucky's northern border, where they'd raised three children, become grandparents, and even

great-grandparents. After marrying in the 50s, the couple had worked on a dairy farm in rural

Boone County, Kentucky,

eventually starting and raising their family. At the time of their deaths, they still lived in Boone

County, but in the moderately sized town of Florence, which is just a 20-minute drive from downtown

Cincinnati, Ohio. A few miles and the Ohio River were all that stood between their neighborhood and the

Queen City. Speaking of their neighborhood, it was a planned subdivision where they had a condo,

and it was decidedly suburban and statistically speaking, a pretty safe place to live.

So this is a far cry from their early years together as dairy farmers.

Exactly. They were not living on an isolated farm or anything like that. Their neighborhood was actually quite populated and busy,

not the type of place for something like this would normally happen. And the neighborhood suited a couple

really well. They lived low-risk lifestyles, leading what journalist Amber Hunt described in an article on

their case as quiet but impactful lives. Bill was semi-retired by then working part-time for an

insurance company. Both Bill and Peggy were particularly involved in their church, where Peggy

played the organ and Bill served as a deacon. Bill had also founded something called the Trucker's Chapel

Ministry, which provided a convenient space at a local truck stop for truck drivers to attend

...