The Great Science Publishing Scandal

Discovery

BBC

Science, Technology

4.3 • 1.2K Ratings

🗓️ 19 August 2019

⏱️ 28 minutes

🔗️ Recording | iTunes | RSS

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Matthew Cobb, Professor of Zoology at the University of Manchester, explores the hidden world of prestige, profits and piracy that lurks behind scientific journals. Each year, hundreds of thousands of articles on the findings on research are published, forming the official record of science. This has been going on since the 17th century, but recently a kind of war has broken out over the cost of journals to the universities and research institutions where scientists work, and to anyone else who wants to access the research, such as policy makers, patient support groups and the general public. Traditionally journals charge their readers a subscription, but since the start of the 21st century there's been a move to what's called open access, where the authors pay to get their articles published but anyone can read them, without charge. In Europe Plan S has called for all research funded by the public purse to be open access, by 2021. If and when this is implemented it could have downsides on learned societies who depend on income from journal subscriptions to support young researchers and on scientists in the less developed world. Some universities, and even countries, have recently refused to pay the subscriptions charged by some of the big science publishers. This has led to some scientists using a service run by a Russian hacker, which has effectively stolen the whole of the scientific literature and gives it away, free, on the internet. Matthew Cobb looks back at how the scientific publishing industry got to its current state and asks how it could change. He argues that scientists themselves need to break their addiction to wanting their articles to appear in a few well known journals, and instead concentrate on the quality of their research.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0	You're about to listen to a BBC podcast and trust me you'll get there in a moment but if you're a comedy fan
0:05.2	I'd really like to tell you a bit about what we do. I'm Julie Mackenzie and I commission comedy
0:10.1	podcast at the BBC. It's a bit of a dream job really. Comedy is a bit of a dream job really.
0:13.0	Comedy is a fantastic joyous thing to do because really you're making people laugh,
0:18.0	making people's days a bit better, helping them process, all manner of things.
0:22.0	But you know, I also know that comedy is really
0:24.3	subjective and everyone has different tastes. So we've got a huge range of comedy on offer from
0:29.8	satire to silly, shocking to soothing, profound to just general pratting about.
0:35.3	So if you fancy a laugh, find your next comedy at BBC Sounds.
0:40.6	This is Discovery from the BBC. You've probably heard something like this many times.
0:47.0	In this week's nature, three Chinese scientists have stuck their necks out by suggesting that we simply don't know enough about the risks and dangers.
0:55.4	But now new research just published in the Lancet overturns the...
0:59.0	Massas Boni Baratti whose analysis appeared this week in science.
1:03.7	I'm Matthew Cobb, professor of zoology at the University of Manchester,
1:08.9	and I'm going to reveal the hidden world of prestige, profits and piracy that lurks behind scientific journals,
1:16.4	a topsy-turvy system that is directly funded by you, the taxpayer.
1:22.4	Each year, hundreds of thousands of articles are published and they form the official
1:26.8	record of science. This has been going on since the 17th century but recently a kind of war has broken out. Publishers have made large profits
1:37.2	charging universities for access to taxpayer-funded research, and in response whole countries have cancelled their journal subscriptions
1:45.6	meaning that tens of thousands of scientists no longer have access to their own
1:50.3	work. To fill the gap many scientists have taken to using a service called
1:55.3	Sci Hub, run by a Kazakh hacker which is effectively stolen the whole of the
	...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Previous episode | Next episode

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from BBC, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of BBC and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.