meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Best of the Spectator

The Edition: does British politics have a problem with the 'omnicause'?

Best of the Spectator

The Spectator

Society & Culture, News Commentary, News, Daily News

4.3 β€’ 826 Ratings

πŸ—“οΈ 27 March 2026

⏱️ 51 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

It is undoubtable that – under the leadership of Zack Polanski – the Green Party have soared to new heights. Having won their first parliamentary by-election in February, polls consistently show them as a force to be reckoned with on the left of British politics. Much of their success has come at the detriment of Labour, with disgruntled further-left progressive voices opting to vote Green. This, though, is a brand of eco-populism that comes at the expense of the Green Party's roots, or so argues Angus Colwell in the Spectator's cover article this week. Have the Greens ceded the issue of the environment?


For this week's Edition, host William Moore is joined by Angus, the Spectator's daily newsletter editor, Life columnist Rachel Johnson and the politics editor of Politics Joe, Ava-Santina Evans. From Nato to nuclear energy, Gaza to trans rights, they discuss whether the Green Party are now guilty of the 'omnicause'; how knowing a person's stance on one subject shouldn't mean their stance on other subjects is obvious.


Plus: how much religion is acceptable in public life? The group discuss shadow Justice Secretary Nick Timothy's recent criticism of the Muslim public prayer at Trafalgar Square. Was Timothy right to say it was an 'act of domination'? Are the Conservatives trying to 'out-Reform Reform' on Islam and extremism? And how do we balance freedom of expression with freedom of religion?


Produced by Patrick Gibbons.


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

The British right is up for grabs. As May's local elections approach, the Conservatives face strong competition from Reform UK.

0:07.9

Join the Spectator's assistant editor, Isabel Hardman, for the spectator debate, the fight for the right, on Wednesday, the 29th of April in London.

0:15.5

We will pit the Conservatives represented by Matthew Saeed and Dominic Johnson against Reform UK, represented by Matt Goodwin and Danny Kruger.

0:23.6

To see which party truly represents the future of the right, book your tickets at spectator.com forward slash fight.

0:36.8

Hello and welcome to the edition from The Spectator.

0:39.9

I'm William Moore, the Spectator's Features Editor.

0:42.7

The latest issue of the magazine has just gone to print, and to talk about what's inside

0:47.4

it, I'm delighted to be joined by The Spectator's Daily Newsletter Editor, Angus Colwell,

0:53.0

our best life columnist, Rachel Johnson, and her dog, Ziggy,

0:57.5

and the politics editor of Politics Joe, Ava Santina Evans.

1:06.9

Our cover this week is Zach Doth,

1:09.5

and in it, Angus argues that under the leadership of

1:12.4

Zach Polansky, the Green Party has become more about Gaza than the environment.

1:18.4

So, Angus, since you've written this excellent cover piece this week, I wondered if you could

1:22.3

just summarise for our listeners and our viewers why you think the Green Party has become more about left-wing

1:30.1

populism now than it has environmentalism? Well, I think nature was a vacuum. So from about 2020 to

1:36.2

2025, you don't have a organised left party in this country. Stama repositioned Labour on the

1:42.1

centre-left and completely posed the Corbynacht from the party. It was a matter of how they were going to organise, I think, and where, rather than if they would. So you have, at the time, all these spinter groups, you can't do it in the Labour Party because the centre had assumed too much control of the party machinery. So then it became basically down to,

2:35.3

does the left want to go with Jeremy Corbyn, or does the left one to go with Zach Polanski? Left side, Polanski, there's less baggage. What this means for the Green Party is, you know, they've always been a party that's done a whole manifesto, you know, like they've not just always been about climate, but climate has been forefront. Now what you have is a broader left populism strategy, which has a lot to do with, as we could see, like Zionism, the Gaza War, Polanski really tapped into the energy on that, particularly when he was elected last year. You see that with their spring conference this weekend, where the Zionism is racism, motion is going to be discussed. And I think this is very interesting because it's Scullet Maguire, the pollster,

2:39.0

makes this point in the piece when I spoke to her. It's very easily forgotten that in 2017,

2:44.2

Jeremy Corbyn issued 40% of the popular vote on a more left-wing platform than he ran on in 2019.

2:48.7

There is an appetite for this stuff. Zach Polanski knows it. And that's why he's repositioning the Greens away from being a climate first party.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from The Spectator, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of The Spectator and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright Β© Tapesearch 2026.