meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
Politics Theory Other

Teaser - PTO Extra! Land of hope and culture wars w/ Nesrine Malik

Politics Theory Other

Politics Theory Other

News

4.8553 Ratings

🗓️ 6 September 2020

⏱️ 3 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

Nesrine Malik joins PTO to speak about the confected media furore over the BBC proms and what it tells us about the UK's culture wars. We also talked about the trajectory of the right wing press and how the left can best respond to the right's cultural turn.

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

So obviously this story is part of a much broader trend. And one of the strange aspects of the so-called

0:06.4

culture wars is that the Conservatives have been in power for a decade. They have an ETC majority.

0:11.2

The Labour Left has been defeated and lost its pretty precarious control of the Labour Party. Brexit is

0:16.2

assured. Right-wing media seems to be thriving. And the BBC never a particularly convincing counterweight to the right-wing press is increasingly cowed.

0:24.1

And yet we see this determination on the right to depict the left as culturally dominant and on the offensive.

0:30.3

Why do you think the right so persistently portrays its project as always embattled and under threat?

0:36.5

Well, because it works. It's incredibly effective and because they really have nothing else to offer,

0:41.3

to offer their voters on an economic level. When you compare previous Tory electoral messages

0:47.3

and the sort of short history of the party to where we are today, there has been a shift from

0:52.3

making promises, making electoral promises, painting a vision

0:57.0

of a country, giving people a sense of social mobility, prospects, or hope, etc., to a very

1:03.0

defensive position that's happened in the US as well, which is that if you vote the other lot

1:07.0

in, what we guarantee you now, which is whatever nominal security order, stability,

1:12.5

closed borders, et cetera, is under threat. And so when you have nothing to offer people,

1:17.1

when you have no economic salvation to offer them, when you have no welfare expansion to offer

1:22.6

them, when you've hacked back the state so drastically, then the only thing you have to offer your voters is a sense of

1:29.9

cultural siege, basically, a sense that they are under attack from other forces. And those forces,

1:35.6

for them to be threatening enough to cast or to spawn a defensive conservative vote,

1:41.7

they have to be framed as incredibly powerful and coordinated

1:45.9

and sinister.

1:46.8

One thing we hear a lot more of recently is this idea of an agenda.

1:50.8

Everybody has an agenda.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Politics Theory Other, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Politics Theory Other and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.