meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Log in
TALKING POLITICS

Paul Mason on the Human Future

TALKING POLITICS

Catherine Carr

News, News & Politics

4.72.5K Ratings

🗓️ 25 April 2019

⏱️ 58 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

We talk to Paul Mason about his new book Clear Bright Future - a radical defence of the human being in the age of digital transformation and a call to political action. The book covers a lot of ground and so do we: Trump and Nietzsche, machine learning and network effects, climate change and neoliberalism, secular humanism and Christian Enlightenment. But no Brexit! A conversation about the biggest political choices we face and the deep philosophical questions that lie behind them. With Helen Thompson.


Talking Points:


How do we demystify technology?

  • In his first book on mechanics, Galileo described machines as things that harness the forces of nature.
  • Likewise, Adam Smith emphasized that labour produces value, not machines.
  • Modern science often likens reality to a computer; but we’ve created them, not the other way around.


AI has the potential to fundamentally transform industrial societies.

  • Civil society needs to have a say in how this technology evolves.
  • How do we introduce ethical questions earlier in the process, instead of building first and asking questions later?


Information has never been more abundant, yet we feel relatively helpless because we have so little control over network effects and the information environment.

  • Information wants to be free, but everywhere it is in chains.
  • Information technology has not created the fourth industrial revolution; it has created social relations of production that are designed to suppress the fourth industrial revolution.


Is there still space in our political discourse for difficult choices? Are we willing to lose things we value if we want things to be better?

  • Paul thinks that civil society needs to refocus on moral philosophy.
  • Paul takes Nietzsche to task and argues that there is a biological basis for universal human rights.


Paul is critical of the effect of neoliberal practice on the human self.

  • He argues that in America, the problem, as Arendt put it, is an alliance of the elite and the mob over “access to history.”
  • The thing to fight for is not just the truth but the possibility of truth.


According to Paul, the left needs to harness the power of the state.

  • He calls himself a “radical social democrat.”
  • He thinks that the left’s failure to project a holistic answer and theory of reality has left the right possessing all of the momentum.


Mentioned in this Episode:


Further Learning:


And as ever, recommended reading curated by our friends at the LRB can be found here: lrb.co.uk/talking

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Hello my name is David Ronserman and this is Talking Politics. Today we're talking to Paul Mason, author, journalist, filmmaker, about his new book which is nothing less than a radical defense of the human being.

0:22.0

Talking Politics is brought to you in partnership with the London Review of Books. As politics speeds up, slow down with the subscription to the LRB where Brexit and Trump are only part of a picture that includes, well everything else.

0:41.0

Read relevant pieces and subscribe at a special rate at lrb.co.uk forward slash talking.

0:53.0

Paul came up to Cambridge to record this conversation on Wednesday morning. We're joined also by Helen Thompson. There is an enormous amount in this book. It's about what it means to be human, it's also about what it means to be political, what it means to be on the left, what it means to be a Marxist.

1:09.0

We're going to try and cover quite a lot of that but it's primarily a book about human beings in the new machine age, the age of digital technology and that's where we started.

1:23.0

A big theme in the book is that we have kind of mystified digital technology and we need to demystify it. We've imbued it with these kind of magical qualities. We often believe that it has powers that we've lost control over and you want us to remember that these are machines or tools even.

1:45.0

And human beings built these things and we can decide how to use them. So just tell us a bit about how you think we've mystified these things but also what the demystification looks like.

1:56.0

Well it was very struck by Galileo's first ever book on mechanics where he writes, I'm surrounded by people who don't know how machines work. At the time, exact contemporaries of Galileo were writing a machine is a thing for defying nature.

2:13.0

And so Galileo just sets to work with his geometry and shows in these 30 pages that indeed a machine is a thing for channeling the forces of nature. Galileo performs in this book the first demystification act.

2:28.0

He says look a machine simply transforms energy, energy in energy out but in a different form. And I was struck by when reading that by the similarity to what Smith does in the wealth of nations.

2:41.0

So Smith says look machines are not creating any of the value. It's the labor that is creating an embodying value in the product. And you can really see that if you go to Kirk-Korri and you think about him, little workshop watching some early steam engine being made.

2:57.0

You can see that it's the people that add the value. So I thought well one thing we have to do about computers is to demystify what they are.

3:08.0

They are machines, software is a machine, a silicon chip is just a machine with the trillion switches that don't move. They neither produce value nor that they produce energy nor do they produce information.

3:23.0

But they do produce vast amounts of utility by transforming the information that goes into them.

3:29.0

Now if you look at it like that, what are you up against? Weirdly, you're up against a heck of a lot of scientists in rocket science, in cosmology, in subatomic physics.

3:42.0

But I've tended to indulge in the metaphysical belief that the universe is a computer. Much like a scientist said you look at carbon to look at the moon and assumes this must be made of wood.

3:57.0

Modern science is full of assertion about reality that likens it to a computer. I just thought no, no, we create them. We can decide what they do.

4:08.0

And we have at the very least the right to a debate about our right to control them.

4:16.0

But what we don't have is the ability to go to Cacodian C, the demystification that comes with actually finding a site where you can watch the machinery in motion.

4:27.0

So part of the mystique of these things is there is something really opaque going on.

4:32.0

What Galileo does and what Smith does, but even more Marx, when Marx I think perfects the labor theory of value, which is what we're talking about, is you have to use abstraction because Marx says in the preface to Das Kapital, you can't perform a chemical experiment on capitalism, you can't refract it, you can't break it down into its elements.

4:50.0

What you have to do is use the power of abstraction to work out what's going on. And I think that what technology is doing is transformative for life on this planet.

...

Please login to see the full transcript.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Catherine Carr, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Catherine Carr and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2026.