Whether it's gossiping over a drink, teaching our children, or politicians debating we use words to communicate with each other and share ideas. It’s what makes us human. But what if we can’t? Could it be possible to broadcast our thoughts directly from our brains without the need for speech? Gaia Vince meets the scientists who say they are getting close to being able to read minds.
For the last decade neuroscientists have been using fMRI brain scanners and EEG to try to communicate with people who’d been diagnosed as being in a persistent vegetative state. They have woken up following a coma but although their eyes are open and they have spontaneous movements, they have no cognitive function and are not capable of higher level thought. Dr Damian Cruse, of Birmingham University, tells Gaia about the results of these experiments.
People with other medical conditions that lead to a loss of speech, such as motor neurone disease, can already communicate with technology. We hear from Sarah Ezekiel, who has had MND since 2000 and whose life has been transformed by being able to talk artificially with eyegaze software on a computer.
Neurologist Dr Kai Miller at Stanford University explains how he is using electrodes already implanted in the brains of people with severe epilepsy to determine what they are seeing.
And Gaia explores the ethical problems that follow from technology that captures thoughts with cognitive scientist and philosopher Dr Adina Roskies of Dartmouth College in the US and Professor Geraint Rees, the editor of a recent collection of essays called "I know what you're thinking: brain imaging and mental privacy". She looks at the controversial privacy issues raised by the technology, such as could someone put thoughts into another's mind?
Image: Fortune teller gazing into a crystal ball, © Creatas
Click on a timestamp to play from that location
0:00.0 | Thank you for downloading from the BBC. |
0:03.0 | The details of our complete range of podcasts and our terms of use, |
0:07.0 | go to BBCworldservice.com slash podcasts. |
0:10.0 | Chatting over a drink. broadcasts. with each other and share ideas. I'm doing it right now. It's what makes us human. But what |
0:26.0 | if we can't? Could it be possible to broadcast our thoughts directly from our brains without |
0:32.1 | the need for speech. There are scientists who say |
0:35.2 | they are getting close to being able to read minds. I'm Gaya Vince and for |
0:41.0 | discovery on the BBC I'll be finding out how. |
0:45.0 | Scientists have been able to question a man thought to have been in a vegetative state by reading his brain activity. |
0:54.6 | The research involved a new brain scanning technique and raises serious moral and medical |
0:59.4 | questions. |
1:00.4 | Our story begins a decade ago when a team in Cambridge announced that they were going to try to see if it was possible to communicate with people who'd been diagnosed as being in a persistent vegetative state. This means they'd had a serious brain injury that resulted in a coma, |
1:17.2 | and from that stage they'd woken up, but although their eyes are open and they have spontaneous movements, they have no cognitive function. |
1:25.4 | They're not capable of higher level thought. |
1:28.0 | They don't respond to their name, for instance. |
1:31.0 | Damien Cruz, now at Birmingham University University was part of the team. |
1:35.8 | By definition these patients are considered to be unaware, to not have any contents of their |
1:41.0 | consciousness if you like. and certainly you know up until around 2006 |
1:46.8 | is that was the prevailing view in the clinical community that these patients |
1:51.6 | really have no mental activity, they have no conscious |
1:55.1 | contents. |
1:56.1 | But then with the work that we've been doing with newer imaging, since then it's shown that some of |
... |
Please login to see the full transcript.
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from BBC, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.
Generated transcripts are the property of BBC and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.
Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.